CSS Solved Pakistan Affairs Past Papers | Write a Detailed and Systematic Analysis of the Charismatic Leadership of Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the Leader of Indian Muslims during the Crisis Ridden Decade of 1937-47
The following question of CSS Pakistan Affairs 2023 is solved by Miss Nishat Afshan, Pakistan’s Best Pakistan Affairs Coach, on the guided pattern of Sir Syed Kazim Ali, which he taught to his students, scoring the highest marks in compulsory subjects for years. This solved past paper question is uploaded to help aspirants understand how to crack a topic or question, how to write relevantly, what coherence is, and how to include and connect ideas, opinions, and suggestions to score the maximum.
Question Breakdown
Question Breakdown
In this question, the examiner has asked you to systematically analyze the charismatic leadership of Jinnah during the crisis-ridden decade of 1937-47. You have to decode the question carefully. Generally, many hints are provided that assist you in attempting the question with the ‘to the point’ approach. So, first, you need to introduce your answer briefly; however, it must contain all the leading points you will insert in your answer. Then, you can write the historical background of the events to contextualize your answer. To enhance the accuracy, one must use the keywords used in the question and try to answer according to these keywords. Then, split your answer into sub-parts and end it with a conclusion. There is no need to add critical analysis separately to the answer, which you write analytically or critically.
Outline
1-Introduction
2-Historical Background of the Political Conditions that Led to the Transformation in Jinnah’s Political Fortunes
3-The Emergence of Jinnah as Quaid-e-Azam (The Great Leader)
- ✓Case in Point: The Lucknow Session of Muslim League-1937 Marked the Transformation in Jinnah’s political fortunes from the Leader of the League to the Mobilizer of a Mass Political Movement; however, his Notion of Grim Resolve Caused him to Earn the Title of Quaid-e-Azam (the Great Leader)
4-Throwing Light on the Charismatic Leadership of Quaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the Leader of Indian Muslims during the Crisis-Ridden Decade of 1937-47
- ✓Constitutional Struggle for a Separate Muslim Homeland-The Lahore Resolution of 1940
- ✓Transforming the All India Muslim League into the Mass Political Movement
- ✓Articulating the Historic Grievances of Muslims
- ✓Highlighting the Notion of Political Distinctiveness
- ✓Surpassing the Obstacles, the Cripps Mission (1942), the Shimla Conference (1945), and Cabinet Mission Plan (1946)
- ✓The Achievement of Pakistan
5-Conclusion
Answer to the Question
Introduction
The decade of 1937-47 was one of the most tumultuous periods in the history of the Indian subcontinent, not only for the Indian Muslims but for all of the Indian masses. However, the undisputed and charismatic leadership of Jinnah, the leader of the All India Muslim League, in the crisis-ridden decade of 1937-47 was instrumental to the creation of Pakistan. Historically, the establishment of the Congress Ministries in 1937-39, where its discriminatory practices raised feelings of insecurity among the Muslims of United India. The failure of Congress Ministries to address the issues of the Muslim community and the way Congress brushed up the role of the Muslim League was a final wake-up call for Jinnah. Thus, he shifted his nationalist tilt from Congress and the British government to the communalist League. The constitutional struggle for a separate state for the Indian Muslims started when he demanded a separate state in the Lahore Resolution of 1940. To execute his plan, he opted to reform the League (AIML) to make its institutional structure efficient to convert it into a large-scale political movement. This tactic led to the victory in the elections of 1945-46, where it secured 533 Muslim seats in the central and provincial assembly elections. Then, he articulated the grievances of Muslims that led to large-scale Muslim Nationalism because there the message reached the Indian masses, causing acceptability among the Indian Muslims that they were united. To attract mass support, he highlighted the notion of political distinctiveness that legitimize his stand. Not going with the Constitutional proposals provided by the British government was instrumental to Jinnah’s ambition of achieving a separate state, so he highlighted the reasons for disagreement with the proposals of Cripps Mission (1942), the Shimla Conference (1945), and Cabinet Mission Plan (1946). Thus, the success of the prolonged struggle of the Muslims on 14th August 1947, the creation of Pakistan, has been attributed to the charismatic leadership of Jinnah.
Historical Background of the Political Conditions that Led to the Transformation in Jinnah’s Political Fortunes
Historically, the crisis-ridden decade of 1937-47 was instrumental to the creation of Pakistan. The Muslims of the Indian subcontinent faced the gravest challenges by the end of the 1930’s. First, the establishment of the Congress Ministries in 1937-39 raised the feeling of insecurity because Congress rejected the formation of a coalition government with the Muslim League. Although it was finalized between the parties to form a coalition before the elections, Congress refused to fulfill the promise. As a result, they sidelined the League and the aspirations of the Muslim community. Jinnah reiterated to Congress that they must be aligned to get rid of the Bureaucratic control of the British and the right of self-determination. However, the Congress rejected the calls of the League. Nehru, the Leader of Congress, said in his speech in January 1937 that there were only two parties in India, the Congress and the British government, and others must line up, and there was no communal problem in India. Jinnah vehemently expressed his views in the Lahore Resolution of 1940 about the inter-communal character of India, regarding it as an International problem that must be treated as such. Indubitably, it was the communal consciousness that led to the birth of the idea of separate electorates among the Indian Muslims. Next, the Government of India Act of 1935 provided a federal democratic form of governmental structure to the Indian subcontinent. The Muslim Leadership was aware that democracy meant Hindu-dominated India. They had not forgotten the betrayal of the Congress after the establishment of the Ministries, so they raised the notion of political distinctness among the mass population to win mass support.
The Emergence of Jinnah as Quaid-e-Azam (The Great Leader)
As I discussed, the failure of Congress Ministries to address the issues of the Muslim community and the way Congress brushed up the role of the Muslim League was a final wake-up call for Jinnah. He was the undisputed leader of the League, so he emerged as the representative of the Muslim community. However, the transformation in his political fortunes started with the Lucknow session of League in 1937, attended by renowned Muslim Leaders, such as Sir Sikandar Hayat- the premier of the Punjab, Khan, Maulvi A.K. Fazlul Haq- the premier of the Bengal and Sir Muhammad Saadullah- the premier of the Assam. The session was a breakthrough in the League’s efforts to mobilize the mass support of Muslims. Thus, Jinnah shifted its tilt from Congress and the British government to the League. Jinnah, the leader of the League, said, Let me tell you – and I tell both of you – that you alone or both combined will never succeed in destroying our souls. You will never be able to destroy that culture, which we have inherited, and you may overpower us, and you can do your worst. But we have concluded, and we have now made a grim resolve that we shall go down if we have to go down, fighting. He reorganized the League and transformed it into a mass political movement. His grim resolve for the cause of Muslims attracted the Muslim community. They declared him their man of movement and savior. Thus, the Muslims and the Muslim leaders of the subcontinent gave him the honorific title of Quaid-e-Azam, a great Leader, in 1938. Concisely, the Lucknow Session of Muslim League-1937 Marked the Transformation in Jinnah’s political fortunes from the Leader of the League to the Mobilizer of a Mass Political Movement; however, his Notion of Grim Resolve Caused him to Earn the Title of Quaid-e-Azam (the Great Leader). At this point, the constitutional struggle for a separate state for the Indian Muslims started when he demanded a separate state in the Lahore Resolution of 1940.
Throwing Light on the Charismatic Leadership of Quaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the Leader of Indian Muslims during the Crisis-Ridden Decade of 1937-47
- ✓Constitutional Struggle for a Separate Muslim Homeland-The Lahore Resolution of 1940
At the point of Congress’s treachery to the League, the constitutional struggle for a separate state for the Indian Muslims started when he demanded a separate state in the Lahore Resolution of 1940. During 1937-40, he highlighted the ideology of two nations in his speeches. He repeatedly emphasized that the right of self-determination is the only solution to the constitutional problems of British India. In his presidential address in the Lahore session of the party on 22nd March 1940, he formally announced the Muslim demand for separate nationhood by emphasizing his stance that Muslims would not agree on any constitution that resulted in a Hindu-majority government. He said that the Musalmans are a nation, according to any definition of a nation, and, like any other free nation, were entitled to a separate homeland to develop to the fullest their spiritual, cultural, economic, social, and political life. The only course open to us is to allow the major nations to separate homelands by dividing India into autonomous national states. He channeled the feelings of the Muslims in Hindu-dominated during the Congress Ministries and transformed the Muslim’s demands into large-scale nationalism.
- ✓Transformed the All India Muslim League into the Mass Political Movement
Then, he decided to reform the AIML to restructure its institutional structure and expand its seats to convert it into large-scale political movements. His strategy consisted of four tasks; first, he expanded its seats so it could be open to more social groups interested in the cause of a separate nation. Second, he gave it a new organizational setup that enabled the participation of people from the grassroots level. As a result, the Muslims, belonging to different social groups, entered into politics and successfully advocated their rights under the party, which gave AIML more power and acceptance as the sole Muslim representative body. The rise of Muslim Nationalism was the testimony that the Muslim urban classes acknowledged that Indian Nationalism was primarily a Hindu nationalism and that Congress was a Hindu-dominated party, representing only Hindus. Third, he concentrated the power in his hands to make the league a well-disciplined party, and here he was facilitated by his charismatic leadership. Then, he formed alliances with the provincial Muslim parties, such as the Unionists. This approach broadened the scope and reach of the party. Hence, this tactic led to the victory in the elections of 1945-46, where it secured 533 Muslim seats in the central and provincial assembly elections.
- ✓Articulated the Historic Grievances of Muslims
Indubitably, the articulation of the complexity of the communal issues of the Indian Muslims gave legitimacy to his stance and boosted the validity of his constitutional struggle for a separate nation. In his mission for the reformation of the All-India Muslim League (AIML), he brought to light the grievances of the Muslim masses they faced during the Congress ministries and the discrimination they had been battling with since the revocation of Partition Bengal in 1911. Furthermore, he channeled the demands of Muslims through his speeches and the League sessions because mass gatherings led to share of ideas and perspectives; however, it became more effective in the presence of an undisputed leader. The awareness led to the acceptability by the Muslims that their future was no safer in Hindu-dominated India. This step of Jinnah led to large-scale Muslim Nationalism because there was great acceptability among the Indian Muslims that they were united and wanted a separate state.
- ✓Highlighted the Notion of Political Distinctiveness
In the Indian subcontinent, the Congress represents the interests of the Muslims and Hindus, and even after the formation of the AIML, some prominent Muslim leaders preferred to remain part of the Congress and also united India. In these circumstances, it seemed impossible for the party to attract large-scale support to become the sole Muslim representative party in the Indian subcontinent. Jinnah knew that the League needed mass support to pursue its interests and demands before the British government, which seemed impossible in the presence of the domination of Congress because already the Hindus had numeric preponderance, and the inclusion of Muslims into Congress strengthened it more. Therefore, he adopted a strategy of highlighting political distinctiveness to attract large-scale support. Hence, the new agenda of the AIML that the party was working for the preservation of the separate ideology of Muslims worked for Jinnah.
- ✓Surpassed the Obstacles, the Cripps Mission (1942), the Shimla Conference (1945), and the Cabinet Mission Plan (1946)
In the same way, not following the constitutional proposals provided by the British government was instrumental to Jinnah’s ambition of achieving a separate state. First, when the Cripps Mission (1942) proposed a dominion status for India, Jinnah highlighted that it lacked immediate self-governance and clarity on the partition demands. Second, when the Shimla Conference (1945) opted to establish an interim government in the Indian subcontinent, he highlighted that the proposal failed to address the issue of Muslim representation. Third, when the Cabinet Mission Plan (1946) provided a three-tier structure by grouping them into clusters based on religion, the Jinnah refused to make a settlement because of the disagreement on the groupings of the provinces. He highlighted that the solution to the constitutional problems of India was no other than granting them the right of self-governance.
- ✓The Achievement of Pakistan
Passing the last mile by not agreeing with the British Plan of united India in 1946, Jinnah knew that the issues ahead were more complex than those passed. It was no other than a passage of the deadly partition process. The complexities created due to the unjust Redcliff Award were much responsible for the atrocities that happened during partition. However, the charismatic leadership of Jinnah caused the completion of the partition process because the Muslim masses trusted their leader. Hence, the prolonged struggle of the Muslims met with success on 14th August 1947.
Conclusion
The decade of 1937-47 was one of the most tumultuous periods that brought the gravest challenges, not only for the Indian Muslims but for all of the Indian masses. The failure of Congress Ministries to address the issues of the Muslim community and the way Congress brushed up the role of the Muslim League shifted Jinnah’s nationalist tilt from Congress and the British government to the communalist League. Then, he demanded a separate state for the Indian Muslims in the Lahore Resolution of 1940. To execute his plan, he opted to reform the League (AIML) to make its institutional structure efficient to convert it into a large-scale political movement. He articulated the grievances of Muslims that led to large-scale Muslim Nationalism. To attract mass support, he highlighted the notion of political distinctiveness that legitimizes his stand. To achieve a separate state, he highlighted the reasons for disagreement with the proposals of the Cripps Mission (1942), the Shimla Conference (1945), and the Cabinet Mission Plan (1946) because all failed to address the issues of the Muslim community. Thus, the success of the prolonged struggle of the Muslims on 14th August 1947, the creation of Pakistan, has been attributed to the charismatic leadership of Jinnah.
CSS 2023 Solved Pakistan Affairs
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
CSS Solved General Science & Ability Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students.
General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers
