PMS Solved Pakistan Affairs Past Papers | Discuss the Obstacles in the Way of Good Governance in Pakistan. In Your View What Steps Can be Taken to Achieve the Goal of Good Governance?
The following question of Pakistan Affairs is solved by Miss Nirmal Hasni, the best Current Affairs coach in Pakistan. Moreover, the question is attempted on the same pattern taught by Sir Syed Kazim Ali to his students, scoring the highest marks in compulsory subjects for years. This solved past paper question is uploaded to help aspirants understand how to crack a topic or question, how to write relevantly, what coherence is, and how to include and connect ideas, opinions, and suggestions to score the maximum.
Outline
1- Introduction
2- Good Governance in Pakistan: Possible or Not?
3- Obstacles in the Way of Good Governance in Pakistan
4- Steps to Inculcate the Good Governance in Pakistan
5- Synthesis
6- Conclusion
Answer to the Question
Introduction:
Good governance is crucial for the sustainable development and progress of any nation. In the case of Pakistan, the path to achieving good governance has been riddled with various obstacles and challenges. These obstacles stem from a combination of historical, political, socio-economic, and institutional factors that have hindered effective governance in the country. Overcoming these obstacles is essential to ensure transparency, accountability, and the delivery of public services to the citizens of Pakistan. This essay will discuss the obstacles in the way of good governance in Pakistan and propose steps that can be taken to achieve this goal.
Good Governance in Pakistan: Possible or Not?
Good governance in Pakistan is undoubtedly a challenging endeavour, considering the complex socio-political landscape and the multitude of obstacles that hinder its realization. However, while the road to achieving good governance may be arduous, it is not an unattainable goal. With concerted efforts, commitment, and strategic reforms, Pakistan can make significant progress towards good governance.
- Political Will and Leadership:
One of the fundamental requirements for good governance is strong political will and visionary leadership. Political leaders must prioritize the principles of transparency, accountability, and public service over personal interests. By demonstrating a commitment to good governance and leading by example, they can inspire positive change and drive the necessary reforms.
- Institutional Reforms:
Strengthening institutions is crucial for promoting good governance in Pakistan. This includes enhancing the independence, capacity, and efficiency of key institutions such as the judiciary, civil service, law enforcement agencies, and electoral bodies. Reforms should focus on merit-based appointments, professional training, and performance evaluation mechanisms to ensure the integrity and effectiveness of these institutions.
- Rule of Law and Anti-Corruption Measures:
Establishing the rule of law and combating corruption is pivotal for achieving good governance. Pakistan needs to strengthen its legal framework, ensure the enforcement of laws, and establish independent anti-corruption bodies. Emphasizing transparency in government processes, implementing effective whistleblower protection mechanisms, and promoting a culture of integrity can help root out corruption and promote good governance.
- Citizen Empowerment and Participation:
Active citizen participation is a cornerstone of good governance. Pakistan should encourage and empower citizens to engage in decision-making processes, provide feedback, and hold public officials accountable. This can be achieved through the promotion of civic education, the establishment of citizen complaint mechanisms, and the inclusion of marginalized groups in decision-making bodies.
- Media Freedom and Civil Society:
A vibrant and independent media, along with a strong civil society, plays a vital role in promoting good governance. Protecting media freedom, ensuring the safety of journalists, and facilitating the work of civil society organizations are essential steps. They can provide a platform for public scrutiny, expose wrongdoing, and advocate for reforms, ultimately contributing to transparency, accountability, and good governance.
- Economic Development and Social Welfare:
Socio-economic development and the provision of basic services are integral to good governance. Pakistan needs to prioritize inclusive economic growth, reduce poverty, and improve access to education, healthcare, and infrastructure. Addressing socio-economic disparities and ensuring the equitable distribution of resources can foster social cohesion and create an environment conducive to good governance.
While the challenges to achieving good governance in Pakistan are significant, it is essential to recognize that progress has been made in certain areas. The country has witnessed advancements in legislation, the establishment of anti-corruption bodies, and improvements in transparency and accountability mechanisms. However, sustained efforts, consistent implementation, and a long-term vision are necessary to overcome the remaining hurdles and ensure a truly transparent, accountable, and participatory governance system. It requires a comprehensive approach encompassing political will, institutional reforms, citizen empowerment, rule of law, and socio-economic development. By addressing these aspects and staying committed to the principles of good governance, Pakistan can pave the way for a prosperous and inclusive future.
Obstacles in the way of Good Governance in Pakistan:
Good governance in Pakistan faces numerous obstacles that impede its progress and hinder the establishment of an effective and accountable governance system. These obstacles are deeply rooted in the country’s historical, political, and socio-economic context. Understanding these challenges is essential for devising strategies to overcome them. Here are some of the key obstacles in the way of good governance in Pakistan:
- Corruption Saga:
Corruption is a pervasive challenge that undermines good governance in Pakistan. It erodes public trust, hampers economic growth, and perpetuates inequality. Widespread corruption affects various sectors, including politics, bureaucracy, judiciary, and law enforcement. Tackling corruption requires robust anti-corruption measures, such as strengthening accountability institutions, promoting transparency, and implementing effective whistleblower protection mechanisms.
- Dysfunctional Institutions:
Pakistan’s institutions often suffer from weaknesses in their capacity, effectiveness, and independence. This undermines the delivery of public services, the rule of law, and the overall governance framework. Strengthening institutions through reforms that focus on merit-based appointments, professional development, and performance evaluation is crucial for improving their functionality and ensuring accountability.
- Chronic Political Instability:
Pakistan has experienced periods of political instability, including frequent changes in governments, weak governance structures, and policy inconsistency. This instability hampers the continuity of policies and reforms, making it difficult to achieve sustainable good governance. Strengthening democratic institutions, promoting political stability, and ensuring a smooth transition of power is essential for fostering good governance.
- Lack of Political Will:
The lack of sustained political will is a significant obstacle to good governance in Pakistan. Political leaders sometimes prioritize short-term gains over long-term reforms, hindering progress in key areas such as anti-corruption, rule of law, and institutional strengthening. Fostering a genuine commitment to good governance and ensuring the continuity of reforms across different political regimes are vital for overcoming this obstacle.
- Socio-economic Challenges:
Socioeconomic challenges, including poverty, unemployment, and income inequality, pose significant hurdles to good governance. These challenges exacerbate social unrest, weaken the social fabric, and hinder effective governance. Addressing these issues through inclusive economic policies, poverty alleviation programs, and investment in human development is necessary for promoting good governance.
- Security Concerns:
Pakistan faces security challenges, including militancy, terrorism, and regional conflicts. These security concerns divert resources, undermine stability, and impede the government’s ability to focus on governance reforms. Establishing peace and stability through effective security measures and addressing underlying causes of conflict is essential for creating an environment conducive to good governance.
- Lack of Citizen Participation:
Limited citizen participation and engagement in decision-making processes hinder good governance. Many citizens feel disconnected from the political system, leading to a lack of accountability and transparency. Encouraging citizen participation through avenues such as public consultations, community involvement, and strengthening local government structures can enhance transparency, responsiveness, and inclusivity in governance.
- Political Patronage and Nepotism:
Pakistan has a history of political patronage, where influential individuals and groups use their connections to gain favours, positions, and resources. This culture of nepotism undermines meritocracy and hampers the selection of qualified and capable individuals for key governmental positions. It perpetuates a system of favouritism and undermines the principles of good governance, which prioritize competence, fairness, and transparency.
- Lack of Effective Public Service Delivery:
Pakistan faces challenges in delivering essential public services effectively. Inefficient bureaucracy, inadequate infrastructure, and limited resources contribute to the poor delivery of services such as healthcare, education, and sanitation. This results in dissatisfaction among the population and a lack of trust in the government’s ability to meet their basic needs.
- Polarized Political Landscape:
Pakistan’s political landscape is often marked by polarization along ethnic, regional, and ideological lines. This polarization hinders consensus-building, compromises, and cooperation among political parties, leading to gridlock and ineffective governance. It becomes challenging to implement comprehensive policies and reforms when there is a lack of political unity and a tendency towards confrontational politics.
- Weak Judicial System:
The judicial system in Pakistan faces challenges related to capacity, efficiency, and independence. Lengthy court proceedings, backlog of cases, and corruption within the judiciary undermine the rule of law and access to justice. Strengthening the judicial system, ensuring judicial independence, and improving its efficiency is crucial for establishing an effective governance framework.
- Lack of Financial Accountability:
Financial mismanagement and lack of accountability contribute to the erosion of good governance. Pakistan faces challenges in terms of fiscal transparency, budgetary control, and misuse of public funds. Strengthening financial accountability mechanisms, enforcing strict auditing practices, and promoting transparency in public financial management is necessary to address this obstacle.
- Influence of Non-State Actors:
Non-state actors, including religious extremist groups and influential interest groups, often exert considerable influence on the political and governance landscape in Pakistan. Their interference can undermine the rule of law, impede policy implementation, and challenge the authority of the state. Effectively addressing this challenge requires comprehensive counter-terrorism measures, promoting social cohesion, and ensuring the state’s monopoly on the use of force.
With sustained dedication and strategic reforms, Pakistan can surmount these obstacles and establish a governance system that promotes transparency, accountability, and public welfare.
Steps to Inculcate Good Governance in Pakistan:
To overcome these obstacles, Pakistan needs a comprehensive and multi-faceted approach. This includes implementing robust anti-corruption measures, strengthening institutions, promoting political stability, investing in socio-economic development, fostering political will, and encouraging citizen participation. Additionally, building strong alliances with international partners, leveraging technological advancements, and fostering a culture of transparency and accountability can also contribute to overcoming these challenges.
- Strengthening Democratic Institutions:
Enhancing the capacity, independence, and effectiveness of democratic institutions, including the parliament, judiciary, and election commission, is crucial. This can be achieved through reforms that ensure transparency, accountability, and the rule of law.
- Promoting Political Stability:
Ensuring political stability is essential for good governance. Encouraging political parties to prioritize national interest over personal or partisan agendas, promoting dialogue and consensus-building, and discouraging disruptive politics can contribute to a stable political environment.
- Enhancing Transparency and Accountability:
Establishing robust mechanisms for transparency and accountability is essential. This includes implementing effective anti-corruption measures, promoting financial transparency, and ensuring the disclosure of assets and incomes of public officials. Strengthening institutions such as the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) can help combat corruption effectively.
- Empowering Local Governance:
Strengthening local government bodies and devolving power to the grassroots level can promote participatory decision-making and effective service delivery. It can also foster a sense of ownership and accountability among local communities.
- Improving Public Service Delivery:
Investing in human resource development, improving infrastructure, and streamlining bureaucratic processes are essential for efficient public service delivery. Implementing e-governance initiatives, promoting citizen-centric approaches, and enhancing the capacity of civil servants can contribute to better service delivery.
- Promoting Citizen Participation:
Encouraging citizen participation in decision-making processes is crucial for good governance. Establishing platforms for public consultations, engaging civil society organizations, and incorporating citizen feedback into policy formulation can ensure that governance decisions are inclusive and representative.
- Strengthening the Rule of Law:
Reforms aimed at strengthening the judicial system, ensuring speedy and fair trials, and addressing issues such as case backlogs and corruption within the judiciary are necessary. Providing adequate resources, training, and support to the legal sector can contribute to an effective and impartial justice system.
- Fostering a Culture of Meritocracy:
Instituting merit-based recruitment and promotion systems in the public sector can help overcome the challenges of nepotism and favouritism. Emphasizing qualifications, skills, and experience in the selection of public officials can contribute to a more efficient and competent bureaucracy.
- Promoting Media Freedom and Freedom of Expression:
Ensuring free and independent media is essential for good governance. Protecting journalists’ rights, encouraging investigative journalism, and facilitating access to information can foster transparency, accountability, and public scrutiny.
- Strengthening Civil Society:
Recognizing the role of civil society organizations in promoting good governance and creating avenues for their active participation can enhance transparency, accountability, and citizen engagement. Providing support and enabling an enabling environment for civil society organizations to operate is crucial.
- Investing in Technology and Awareness:
Prioritizing education and awareness programs can empower citizens with the knowledge and skills necessary for active participation in governance processes. Promoting civic education, media literacy, technical education and civic engagement programs can foster a culture of good governance via E-governance.
Implementing these steps requires commitment, political will, and sustained efforts from all stakeholders, including the government, civil society, and citizens. It is a gradual and ongoing process that requires continuous evaluation and adaptation to address emerging challenges and ensure sustainable good governance in Pakistan.
Synthesis:
Obstacles in the way of good governance in Pakistan are numerous and multifaceted. Some of the key challenges include political instability, corruption, weak institutional capacity, lack of transparency and accountability, inadequate service delivery, and limited citizen participation. These obstacles undermine effective governance and hinder the country’s progress.
To achieve the goal of good governance in Pakistan, several steps can be taken, encompassing the Strengthening of democratic institutions; Reforms should focus on enhancing the capacity, independence, and effectiveness of institutions such as the parliament, judiciary, and election commission. This can be done by promoting transparency, accountability, and the rule of law. Combating corruption; Implementing robust anti-corruption measures and strengthening institutions like the National Accountability Bureau can help address corruption. Transparency in financial transactions and the disclosure of assets and incomes of public officials should be ensured.
Empowering local governance; Devolving power to local government bodies can foster participatory decision-making and accountability. It can also improve service delivery and address the needs of local communities more effectively. Improving public service delivery; Investments should be made in human resource development, infrastructure, and streamlining bureaucratic processes. Embracing e-governance initiatives and citizen-centric approaches can enhance the quality and efficiency of public services. Promoting citizen participation; Creating platforms for public consultations, engaging civil society organizations, and incorporating citizen feedback into policy-making processes can ensure inclusivity and representation in governance decisions. Strengthening the rule of law; Reforms should focus on enhancing the judicial system, ensuring fair and speedy trials, and addressing issues such as case backlogs and corruption within the judiciary. An effective and impartial justice system is crucial for good governance.
Fostering meritocracy; Instituting merit-based recruitment and promotion systems in the public sector can reduce nepotism and favouritism. Emphasizing qualifications, skills, and experience in the selection of public officials can contribute to a more competent and efficient bureaucracy. Promoting media freedom and freedom of expression; Protecting journalists’ rights, encouraging investigative journalism, and facilitating access to information can foster transparency, accountability, and public scrutiny. Strengthening civil society; Recognizing and supporting the role of civil society organizations in promoting good governance is vital. Providing an enabling environment for their operation and active participation can enhance transparency, accountability, and citizen engagement. Investing in education and awareness; Prioritizing education and awareness programs can empower citizens with the knowledge and skills necessary for active participation in governance processes. Promoting civic education, media literacy, and civic engagement programs can foster a culture of good governance.
In the book “Governing the Ungovernable: Institutional Reforms for Democratic Governance” by Ishrat Hussain, the author explores the challenges of achieving good governance in Pakistan. He acknowledges the existing obstacles and complexities in the country’s governance system but remains optimistic about the possibility of improving governance practices. Hussain highlights key issues such as corruption, weak institutions, political instability, and bureaucratic inefficiencies that hinder good governance. He emphasizes the need for comprehensive institutional reforms to address these challenges and establish effective governance mechanisms. The book suggests practical steps to enhance transparency, accountability, and meritocracy within the government. It proposes measures like strengthening civil service reforms, promoting decentralization, empowering local governments, and fostering inclusive decision-making processes.
Hussain’s work emphasizes the importance of political will, leadership, and the active participation of citizens in shaping the governance landscape. While acknowledging the complexities, the book offers a roadmap for achieving good governance in Pakistan by advocating for institutional reforms, effective policy implementation, and a commitment to democratic principles.
Conclusion:
The root of the matter is that achieving good governance in Pakistan is a complex task due to the various obstacles that hinder its progress. These obstacles include political instability, corruption, weak institutions, lack of transparency and accountability, inadequate service delivery, and limited citizen participation. However, by implementing a comprehensive set of steps, it is possible to overcome these challenges and pave the way for good governance in the country. Some of the key steps that can be taken include strengthening democratic institutions, combating corruption, empowering local governance, improving public service delivery, promoting citizen participation, strengthening the rule of law, fostering meritocracy, promoting media freedom and freedom of expression, strengthening civil society, and investing in education and awareness. These measures, if implemented with dedication and commitment, have the potential to foster transparency, accountability, citizen engagement, and effective decision-making processes.
However, it is important to acknowledge that achieving good governance is a long-term endeavour that requires sustained efforts, political will, and collaboration among government, civil society, and citizens. It is crucial to regularly evaluate progress, adapt strategies, and address emerging challenges to ensure the continued improvement of governance practices. By addressing the obstacles and implementing the necessary steps, Pakistan can strive towards achieving good governance, which will not only contribute to the overall development and prosperity of the country but also enhance the trust and confidence of its citizens in the governance systems.
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
PMS 2022 Solved Pakistan Affairs
| 1- | Compare and contrast the role of ECO and SAARC for the regional connectivity and stability. |
| 2- | We need “Friends not Masters”. Critically evaluate Pakistan’s likely relations with United States of America after its withdrawal from Afghanistan. |
| 3- | The Ulema of Nadwah attempted to make a synthesis of modernism of Aligarh and conservatism of Deoband in their syllabus. Discuss. |
| 4- | The location of Pakistan has given the strategic strength to the State. What are its physical features and narrate its advantages and disadvantages? |
| 5- | Separation of East-Pakistan, though a tragic part of History of Pakistan, was not the negation of Two-Nation theory.” Discuss. |
| 6- | Discuss the obstacles in the way of good governance in Pakistan. In your view what steps can be taken to achieve the goal of good governance? |
| 7- | Write short notes on any TWO of the following: a. Constitutional Amendment b. Kashmir Dispute c. Pakistan’s Role in the United Nations |
Articles Might Interest You!
The following are some of the most important articles for CSS and PMS aspirants. Click on any to start reading.
