CSS Pakistan Affairs | Pakistan’s Joining of the USA Block in Cold War
The following question of CSS Current Affairs is solved by Hinas Khan Yusafzai under the supervision of Howfiv’s Pakistan Affairs and Current Affairs Coaches. She learnt how to attempt 20 marks question and essay writing from Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Pakistan’s best CSS and PMS English essay and precis teacher with the highest success rate of his students. This solved past paper question is attempted on the pattern taught by Sir to his students, scoring the highest marks in compulsory and optional subjects for years, and uploaded to help aspirants understand how to crack a topic or question, how to write relevantly, what coherence is, and how to include and connect ideas, opinions, and suggestions to score the maximum.
Outline
1- Introduction
2-Aerial view on Pakistan – US relationships
3-Difference between US and USSR ideologies
4-Why did Pakistan prefer joining the US block during the Cold War after its emergence?
- ✓ The concerns of economic interest
- ✓ Fear of Indian dominance in the region
- ✓ The security concern from Soviet expansion
- ✓ Protection of Islamic identity by containment of communism
- ✓ Geopolitical location and Global politics
5- On what grounds joining the USA block was not a good idea?
- ✓ Over-dependence on foreign aid
- ✓ Loss of sovereignty
- ✓ Involvement in regional conflicts
- ✓ Reputation tainted by terrorism
- ✓ Cultural homogenization and economic constraints
6-Critical Analysis
7-Conclusion
Answer to the Question
Introduction
During the Cold War, when there were two superpowers, the US and the USSR, but Pakistan aligned itself with the US block, the decision was driven by its desire for international recognition and economic support. However, this decision ultimately proved detrimental to the nation’s autonomy and development. By joining the US bloc, Pakistan became entrenched in a cycle of dependency on foreign aid, compromising its sovereignty and self-sufficiency. This alliance also drew Pakistan into regional conflicts, tarnished its reputation due to associations with terrorism, and led to cultural homogenization. Moreover, economic policies were dictated by US interests, rather than Pakistan’s needs. In retrospect, Pakistan’s decision to ally with the US, rather than exploring alternative partnerships like the Soviet Union’s offered economic cooperation, has had far-reaching and detrimental consequences. Hence, this answer addresses that Pakistan’s Cold War-era alliance with the US has had lasting repercussions.
Aerial view on Pak-US relations
- 1947 Diplomatic relations were laid out after Pakistan acquired freedom.
- The 1950s-1960s Agreements on military assistance, cooperation in defence, and water Sharing were signed.
- 1970 U.S. support during Indo-Pak clashes and Soviet intrusion into Afghanistan.
- 1980 Pakistan received assistance from the United States to support Afghan mujahedeen in their fight against the Soviets.
- 1990 Warrant forced over atomic multiplication concerns.
- 2001 Pakistan becomes a crucial ally in the US-led war on terrorism (WOT) after the 9/11 attacks.
- 2004 The U.S. made Pakistan a major non-NATO ally.
- 2011 U.S. powers killed Osama Canister loaded in a secretive activity in Abbottabad, Pakistan, prompting a strain in relations.
- 2018 Pakistan’s support for militant groups has prompted the United States to suspend its military assistance.
- 2019 Peace talks between the United States and the Taliban in Afghanistan are made easier by Pakistan.
- 2021 Concerns about the stability of the region and Pakistan’s role are being raised as the U.S. troops withdraw from Afghanistan.
- 2022 The dismissal of Imran Khan amid public accusations of a U.S. conspiracy.
- 2023 US-Pakistan cooperation on Afghanistan, counter-terrorism, and economic partnership has been discussed.
- 2024 The US and Pakistan renewed diplomatic engagement, expanded investment, and climate change cooperation is currently expected.
Difference between USA and USSR ideologies
To begin with, it is essential to understand the difference between the ideologies of the USA and the USSR.
The United States represents democratic capitalism, emphasizing individual freedom and rights, a free market economy, and limited government intervention. The system promotes private enterprise, entrepreneurship, and representative democracy, protecting property rights. Also, the US advocates for the global spread of democracy and capitalism, prioritizing individual autonomy. In contrast, the Soviet Union represented communist socialism, focusing on collective ownership of resources and a state-planned economy. The government-controlled production and distribution, aiming for a classless society with equal social welfare. Communist ideology emphasized atheistic secularism and sought to spread its influence globally.
Why did Pakistan prefer joining the US block during the Cold War after its emergence?
Pakistan preferred joining the USA bloc during the Cold War era for several reasons these are given below:
- The concerns of Economic needs
Pakistan needed economic aid and investment for its progress and development, which the US provided. For instance, the US Agency for International Development, in 1955, provided significant economic assistance to Pakistan, including $3.2 billion to the country. In the 1950s, Pakistan’s government sought to establish friendly relations with both the Soviet Union and the US. However, the USSR’s rebuff of Pakistan’s request for military aid and the US’s extension of an invitation to Ayub Khan for a state visit in 1950 shifted Pakistan’s focus towards the US. This marked the beginning of a close relationship between the two countries. Hence, Pakistan’s economic reliance on the US deepened, making an alliance more necessary at that time.
- Fear of India’s dominance
Pakistan’s decision to align with the United States during the Cold War era was primarily driven by two factors: fear of Indian dominance and concern over Soviet expansion. In fact, the 1947 partition of British India created a longstanding rivalry between Pakistan and India, exacerbated by the Kashmir dispute. For instance, Indian hegemony and security concerns led Pakistan to fear Indian dominance in the region, particularly after India’s annexation of Hyderabad (1948) and Goa (1961). Pakistan sought protection from potential Indian aggression, especially after the 1947 Indo-Pakistani War over Kashmir. Thus, Pakistan felt threatened by India’s larger size, population, and military.
- The concern over Soviet expansion
Pakistan sought US military aid and cooperation to counterbalance Soviet expansion. For instance, Soviet influence in Afghanistan and communist presence in the region, which led to the 1979 Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, heightened Pakistan’s concerns about Soviet expansionism. To counter this threat, Pakistan sought US military aid and cooperation, forging a strategic partnership to bolster its defences. The 1979 Soviet invasion of Afghanistan heightened Pakistan’s anxieties, as it feared Soviet expansion would compromise its sovereignty. Hence, Pakistan was worried about the spread of communism in the region, particularly in Afghanistan and India.
- Protection of Islamic identity by containment of communism
Pakistan saw alignment with the US as a means to protect its Islamic identity and counter potential Soviet-backed communist or secular influences. As an illustration, in US-Pakistan Military Aid Agreement 1954, Pakistan signed a military aid agreement with the US, securing financial and military assistance. Also, Pakistan saw the US as a bulwark against the spread of communism in the region. Pakistan’s President Ayub Khan, 1958, stated, “Communism is a threat to our way of life”. Hence, Pakistan’s alignment with the US helped contain communism. leaders like Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Ayub Khan, and Zia-ul-Haq inclined towards the US, seeing an alliance as beneficial for Pakistan.
- Geopolitical location and Global politics
Pakistan’s strategic location at the crossroads of the Middle East, South Asia, and the Soviet Union made it an important player in the Cold War. For that reason, the US recognized Pakistan’s significance, in the 1950s when Pakistan joined the Western-backed alliances, SEATO and CENTO Thus, this location allowed Pakistan to monitor Soviet activities and provide a counterbalance to Soviet influence in the region. However, the bipolar world order of the Cold War era forced countries to choose sides, making it difficult for Pakistan to remain neutral. Pakistan’s Foreign Minister, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, in 1958, stated, “We have to make a choice between the Western bloc and the Communist bloc.” Therefore, for such reason Pakistan join the US block.
On what grounds joining the USA block was not a good idea
The decision to align with the USA bloc continues to shape Pakistan’s foreign policy and relationships with neighbouring countries. Also, Pakistan’s alignment with the US provided temporary security benefits but ultimately led to many obstacles in its way the major challenges till now Pakistan is dealing with re discussed below:
- Dependence on foreign aid
Pakistan’s decision to join the US bloc led to a chronic dependence on foreign aid, which has persisted till today. As per Congressional Research Service, the US has historically provided significant economic assistance, with $73 billion in aid between 1951 and 2019 in 2002, the US has provided over $14 billion in military aid. The country’s reliance on US economic and military assistance began in the 1950s and continued throughout the Cold War era. This dependency has had far-reaching consequences. Pakistan’s military has become heavily reliant on US military aid, compromising its sovereignty. This dependence has limited Pakistan’s ability to develop its own defence industry and make independent foreign policy decisions. Hence, Pakistan’s dependence on foreign aid has compromised its international relations. The country’s close ties with the US have strained relationships with neighboring countries, particularly Iran and Afghanistan.
- Loss of sovereignty and Decision-making power
Pakistan’s decision to join the US bloc during the Cold War era has resulted in a significant loss of sovereignty, compromising its ability to make independent decisions. In fact, the US has consistently influenced Pakistan’s foreign policy, often prioritizing American interests over Pakistani concerns. For instance, Pakistan’s participation in the US-led War on Terror led to widespread drone strikes, resulting in significant civilian casualties and erosion of Pakistan’s control over its airspace. Also, The US has also pressured Pakistan to support its regional policies, including sanctions against Iran and support for Saudi Arabia in the Yemen conflict. This has strained Pakistan’s relationships with neighbouring countries and compromised its ability to pursue independent foreign According to the former Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan has publicly criticized Pakistan’s loss of sovereignty, stating, “We have become a country that is subservient to the US.” Thus, the US has always interfered in Pakistan’s domestic politics, often backing specific political parties or leaders, which caused Pakistan to lose its sovereignty.
- Involvement in regional conflicts
Pakistan’s alignment with the USA block has led to its involvement in various regional conflicts, often at the behest of the US. First, Pakistan’s participation in the US-led War on Terror, including the invasion of Afghanistan in 2001, has led to a prolonged conflict along its western border. This has resulted in significant human and economic costs, including over 70,000 casualties and $120 billion in losses. Second, Pakistan’s involvement in regional conflicts has also led to internal instability, including the rise of militant groups and sectarian violence. According to the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, 2023, the US drone strike campaign in Pakistan’s tribal regions has contributed to this instability. The US has also pressured Pakistan to support its policies in the Middle East, including the Saudi-led intervention in Yemen. Thus, Pakistan’s involvement in this conflict has strained its relationships in its region.
- Reputation tainted by terrorism
Pakistan’s alignment with the USA bloc has severely tainted its reputation, with the country being perceived as a hub for terrorism. First, Pakistan’s support for US-backed mujahedeen groups in the 1980s Afghan conflict created a culture of jihadism, which eventually gave rise to terrorist organizations like the Taliban and al-Qaeda. Second, the US-led War on Terror post-9/11 further entrenched Pakistan’s reputation as a haven for terrorists. Third, the discovery of Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad in 2011 reinforced global perceptions of Pakistan’s complicity in terrorism. Pakistan’s inability to curb terrorist groups operating within its borders, such as the Haqqani Network and Lashkar-e-Taiba, has led to international criticism and sanctions. According to the Former US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton,2019, stated, “Pakistan is essentially providing a safe haven for terrorists.” Hence, the US has repeatedly designated Pakistan as a “terrorist- safe-haven” country, citing its failure to address terrorist financing and ideology has tainted its global reputation.
- Cultural homogenization and economic constraints
Pakistan’s Cold War-era alliance with the US had profound repercussions, culminating in the erosion of its cultural distinctiveness and economic autonomy. In fact, Pakistan has embraced Western influences, its traditional Islamic values and customs began to fade, replaced by foreign norms and lifestyles. Simultaneously, the nation’s economy became increasingly reliant on foreign aid, particularly from the US, stifling its potential for self-sustaining growth. This dependency led to structural vulnerabilities, including a lack of economic diversification and heightened susceptibility to external economic shocks. Pakistan’s decision-making power was also compromised, as US interests often took precedence over domestic priorities. For instance, cultural homogenization has diluted Pakistan’s unique Islamic identity, and economic constraints have hindered growth and increased vulnerability, which has compromised its autonomy and limited Pakistan’s policy independence, along with regional conflicts that have spawned instability and extremism. Thus, Pakistan’s Cold War-era alliance with the US has had lasting impacts on its cultural fabric and economic trajectory, underscoring the importance of cautious diplomacy and strategic decision-making in international relations.
Critical Analysis
Under the critical lens, Pakistan’s decision to align itself with the US block during the Cold War has proven to be a detrimental choice, compromising its sovereignty and tarnishing its global reputation. The US provided economic assistance, but only in the form of tied aid and loans, creating a cycle of dependency that undermined Pakistan’s ability to pursue its national interests. Instead, Pakistan should have adopted a non-aligned foreign policy, maintaining equidistance from both the US and USSR. This would have allowed Pakistan to diversify its economic partnerships, pursue independent decision-making, avoid entanglement in regional conflicts, foster stronger ties with neighboring countries and to develop a self-sustaining economy. However, by doing so, Pakistan could have preserved its sovereignty, promoted regional stability, and cultivated a more balanced relationship with global powers.
Conclusion
Towards the Crux, Pakistan’s decision to ally with the US during the Cold War proved to be disastrous, compromising its sovereignty and sparking a damaging cycle of dependency. Joining of the US block has made Pakistan became mired in regional conflicts, terrorism, and economic exploitation. Thus, embracing non-alignment would have also enabled Pakistan to capitalize on economic opportunities from both blocs, rather than relying on exploitative US aid.
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
CSS Solved Islamiyat Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ Islamiyat Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS Islamiyat coach having the highest score of their students.
CSS Solved Islamiyat
CSS Solved General Science & Ability Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students.
CSS Solved General Science and Ability
