The following article, “Fixing Political Polarization in Pakistan”, is written by Syeda Sonia Haider, a student of Sir Syed Kazim Ali. Moreover, the article is written on the same pattern, taught by Sir to his students, scoring the highest marks in compulsory subjects for years. Sir Kazim has uploaded his students’ solved past paper questions so other thousands of aspirants can understand how to crack a topic or question, how to write relevantly, what coherence is, and how to include and connect ideas, opinions, and suggestions to score the maximum.
Outline
1-Introduction
2-Debunking political polarization
3-Political Polarization in Pakistan: Current Situation
4-Why has fixing political polarization become an issue of the day in Pakistan?
- ✓Ethnic and regional diversity
- ✓Political leadership exploiting divisions
- ✓Military Interventions
- ✓External Factor
5-What impacts has the unfixed political polarization in Pakistan created in the country?
- ✓Community Fragmentation
- ✓Erosion of Democratic Norms
- ✓Stalled Reforms
- ✓Undermining Critical Thinking
6-How can Pakistan fix political polarization in the country?
6.1-To strengthen institutions and governance
- ✓Promote Institutional Independence
- ✓Enhance Transparency and Accountability
- ✓Reform Electoral Processes
- ✓Policy Consistency
6.2-To encourage inclusive political dialogue
- ✓National Reconciliation
- ✓Negotiate Solutions
- ✓Civic Education
6.3-To introduce media and information reforms
- ✓Media Literacy Programs
- ✓Regulating Media Bias
- ✓Support Fact-Checking Initiatives
6.4-To endorse civil society engagement
- ✓Support Civil Society Initiatives
- ✓Youth Engagement
6.5-To promote leadership and Political Behaviour
- ✓Exemplary leadership
- ✓Conflict Resolution Mechanisms
6.6-To ensure economic development and social welfare
- ✓Economic Opportunities
- ✓Social Welfare Programs
6.7-International Engagement and Support
- ✓International Assistance
7-Conclusion
Answer to the Question
1-Introduction
Political polarization in Pakistan has alarmingly emerged as a disturbing aspect of socio-political landscape, significantly impacting the nation’s stability and progress at large. The deep-rooted divisions along political, ideological, and societal lines have led to a fragmented political environment, hindering effective governance and impeding the country’s development socially, politically, and economically. Hate and bizarre language, religious cards, self-satisfying allegations, accusations, and subjugating punishments for the opponents are creating fissures and intolerance in society, destroying the deep-down peace and harmony in the nation. The origins of political polarization in Pakistan can be traced back to historical, cultural, and socio-economic factors, compounded by regional disparities, divergent political narratives, and many other external factors. This polarization has manifested in various forms, such as social fragmentation, economic instability, and unawareness, affecting the nation across the boards. However, addressing political polarization in Pakistan requires a multi-faceted approach involving all stakeholders, including political factions, civilians, religious factions, media, and regional communities, promoting inclusivity and fostering a more cohesive and unified national identity. This article mainly discusses how Pakistan can fix political polarization in the country, along with the causes and impacts behind the evil.
2-Debunking political polarization
Debunking political polarization, it is a multi-faceted approach which challenges misconceptions and misunderstandings that fuel divisions among different political groups. It is essential for healing societal divisions as it dismantles misconceptions, promotes empathy, and nurtures a balanced political system. Addressing political polarization helps foster critical thinking, where individuals actively seek diverse perspectives and reliable information to challenge their beliefs. Therefore, the complexities within political ideologies are addressed, and mutual values, goals and beliefs are emphasized to bridge divides. In this way, misconceptions, stereotypes, and myths preserved and nurtured by polarized political systems and corrupt institutions are exposed, thus enabling people to have a comprehensive understanding of governance, power dynamics, and civic engagement. However, through education, open discourse, and emphasizing common goals, societies can strive towards a more unified and empathetic future, thus debunking polarization and helping in the country’s social, economic and political development.
3-Political Polarization in Pakistan: Current Situation
Currently, Pakistan has constantly been grappling with significant political polarization in the past. However, the divide has been pronounced since last year when an ex-PM was over toppled from power, disturbing the socio-economic structure of the whole country. Because of the political and ideological rift between two major political parties, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) led by Prime Minister Imran Khan and the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) led by Nawaz Sharif, the country have witnessed a tense political environment. Moreover, the military’s involvement in political affairs has exacerbated the already polarized environment, resulting in a severe trust deficit between civilians and the military for the first time in the history of Pakistan. The issue between the political parties and establishment has arisen on issues surrounding governance, allegations of corruption, economic challenges, and differing approaches to foreign policy. These divisions and political chaos have led to many challenges, such as policy-making, legislative processes, and maintaining stability within the government. Therefore, addressing the deep-rooted issues and fostering an inclusive political environment remains crucial for the country’s socio-economic stability. As said by Aristotle:
“With political tolerance, economic equality, and civic participation comes stability.”
4-Why has fixing political polarization become an issue of the day in Pakistan?
Ironically, political polarization has profound roots in the country, leading from historical, social, and institutional factors to regional disparities, religious differences, and divergent political narratives. Some main reasons for political division in the country are written as follows.
Ethnic and Regional Diversity
First, Pakistan, a home to different racial groups with distinct identities and interests, has an odd history of religious, ethnic, and regional differences. These groups fight for power and resources. Most of the time, these differences have burst out loud in the form of political differences, contributing to a polarized environment at large. For instance, the Mohajirs in Sindh, mainly represented by the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), have historically felt marginalized, leading to tensions and political rifts. Therefore, ethnic and regional diversity in Pakistan has contributed to political polarization.
Political Leadership Exploiting Divisions
Second, politicians and political parties, to gain support from the general public, sometimes use rhetoric that deepens existing fault lines for their advantage. Political leaders, such as the Sharif-led PML-N and the Bhutto-led PPP, have historically exploited these divisions to consolidate power bases, perpetuating the cycle of polarization. Hence, political leaders have also created political tension in the country.
Military Interventions
Third, Pakistan has had a very obvious and significant instance of direct or indirect military interventions in political affairs. It’s no longer a secret that the military tries to influence political affairs if its interests are threatened in any way. These direct and indirect military coups have undermined the stability and trust of the country’s general population in democratic governance, thus leading to severe social, economic, and political disturbance.
External Factors
Lastly, Pakistan’s geopolitical location, along with the international influence of major global powers, such as the US, Russia and China, has permanently affected its internal politics, leading to polarization based on alliances, loyalties, or ideologies associated with external entities. Whether it’s the geopolitical tensions concerning India and Afghanistan, a Saudi-Iran rivalry based on sectarianism, or an economic war between the US and China, political tension seeps into internal politics, disturbing the country’s peace within. Therefore, there have been many external factors which exacerbate the political polarization in the country.
5-What impacts has the unfixed political polarization in Pakistan created in the country?
Moving ahead, it is evident that political polarization in the country significantly affects its social cohesion and unity. Some possible social, political, economic, and educational impacts in this regard are as follows.
Community Fragmentation
Sadly, political polarization strengthens the divide among people who already have different ideologies or ways of thinking, making communities isolated. As in ethnically diverse Karachi, the prolonged political polarization has led to segregated neighborhoods, limiting interactions and fostering distrust among different ethnic groups.
Erosion of Democratic Norms
Further, democratic norms and political institutions weaken because of continuous political disturbance. They can undermine democratic norms due to aggressive public opinion and lackluster attitude of institutions. Thus, undemocratic tactics become a norm to fulfil their political agenda, undermining the state’s transparency, accountability, and fairness.
Stalled Reforms
Moreover, essential economic reforms and constitutional amendments become difficult to pass in a politically divided legislative house. Vital economic policies in the interests of the general public, such as those related to taxation, trade, and infrastructure development, may get delayed or diluted due to political disagreements. Therefore, pragmatic reforms that have the potential to spur economic growth and development are often put on hold.
Undermining Critical Thinking
Last but not least, polarized educational environments hinder the development of critical thinking skills and a child’s instinct to understand right and wrong, for students exposed to one-sided and biased narratives and lack exposure to diverse perspectives could not think critically nor even form their independent opinions. Hence, political awareness has become a far-fetched dream in Pakistan, essential to integrate the federating country.
6-How can Pakistan fix political polarization in the country?
However, fixing political polarization in Pakistan requires a comprehensive, multi-faceted approaches, addressing various aspects of society and sincere efforts to build a strong nation. Here are several suggestions discussed that will restrict and alleviate the deep-rooted political polarization in Pakistan.
6.1-To strengthen institutions and governance
- ✓Promote Institutional Independence
The first in the row is ensuring institutional independence and impartiality of the judiciary, election commission, and media from political influence fosters impartiality and credibility, significantly contributing to reduce politically polarized Pakistan.
- ✓Enhance Transparency and Accountability
Adding more to it, transparency in government operations, public access to information, and mechanisms for holding officials accountable for their actions reduce suspicions of favouritism or corruption, fostering trust among citizens of Pakistan.
- ✓Reform Electoral Processes
Next, a neutral and unbiased electoral process promotes fairness, transparency, and inclusivity, reducing allegations of electoral fraud or bias. This, eventually, reduces the scope for polarization during elections.
- ✓Policy Consistency
More importantly, well-functioning institutions contribute to policy consistency, reducing uncertainty and minimizing factors that contribute to political polarization. Policy stability, therefore, is inevitable to provide a predictable environment for political engagement.
6.2-To encourage inclusive political dialogue
- ✓National Reconciliation
In the way of encouraging inclusiveness, encouraging dialogue and reconciliation among different political and racial-ethnic factions on the same platform to let them express their viewpoints and address their fundamental issues fosters understanding among opposing groups, making the environment less polarized. So, finding common grounds and managing consensus-building rather than perpetuating divisive narratives is helpful in mitigating a polarized climate.
- ✓Negotiate Solutions
Similarly, open discussions and inclusive political dialogues always clarify misunderstandings that fuel polarization. Therefore, reaching mutually beneficial solutions helps overcome rigid stances and prevents the entrenchment of extreme viewpoints that further polarization.
- ✓Civic Education
Likewise, promoting civic education programs in Pakistan that encourage civil participation as active and responsible participants in shaping the nation’s political discourse is definitely going to help society become less polarized. Hence, fostering a better understanding of democratic principles, tolerance, and respect for diverse opinions among citizens, especially in schools and communities, prevents the escalation of disputes that could deepen divisions within society and politics.
6.3-To introduce media and information reforms
- ✓Media Literacy Programs
In the pursuit of introducing programs to enhance media literacy among the public, teaching critically analyzing information sources and discerning between facts and opinions encourage citizens to explore information objectively rather than being influenced by biased narratives. So, understanding biases and acting shrewdly to not let them pollute society reduce susceptibility to polarized misinformation.
- ✓Regulating Media Bias
Besides this, implementing regulations or guidelines on the state level to ensure balanced reporting and reduce biased narratives, including sensationalism, in news and talk shows and in the coverage of political events to minimize the reinforcement of polarized viewpoints.
- ✓Support Fact-Checking Initiatives
Moreover, encouraging fact-checking organizations in Pakistan to help spread verified information on print, electronic and social media reduce the threat of misleading narratives that manipulate the public. So, combating false information and deceptive narratives contributes to a less polarized society, focusing on the positive side of every development.
6.4-To endorse civil society engagement
- ✓Support Civil Society Initiatives
Endorsing civil society organizations that promote dialogue, tolerance, and understanding among different societal groups will surely promote inclusivity and foster cooperation and shared values between various factions of society. Therefore, these organizations can be helpful in mitigating polarized environments as they provide space for dialogue and negotiation among citizens, politicians and community stakeholders.
- ✓Youth Engagement
On the top of it, empowering and involving youth in civic and political activities builds networks that bridge divides between different societal groups. Therefore, educating and engaging youth in leadership development provides many untapped opportunities, promoting collaboration, understanding, and collective problem-solving despite ideological differences.
6.5-To promote leadership and Political Behaviour
- ✓Exemplary leadership
Further, political leaders exhibiting respectful behaviour for opponents and propagating sophisticated behaviour during debates, discussions, and public appearances can set an example for followers and constituents. Therefore, Pakistan’s leaders should prioritize national interests rather than partisan gains, demonstrating respect and encouraging followers to adopt a more open-minded approach and a more constructive political culture, reducing hostility and polarization.
- ✓Conflict Resolution Mechanisms
Similar to this, developing and encouraging effective conflict resolution mechanisms within the political parties of Pakistan can reduce grievances and mitigate the social divide that contributes to polarization. This inclusivity can help reduce animosity and promote cooperation among rival factions.
6.6-To ensure economic development and social welfare
- ✓Economic Opportunities
Most importantly, economic development initiatives can create opportunities, reducing grievances and inequalities that fuel political polarization. By providing equal access to education, healthcare, and employment opportunities, the government of Pakistan can thus minimize the divide between different social and racial groups having diverse viewpoints.
- ✓Social Welfare Programs
In the same manner, implementing social welfare programs creates a more inclusive society by ensuring all population segments benefit from progress. Therefore, social welfare programs aimed at reducing divisions based on economic disparities in Pakistan can help in poverty alleviation, healthcare accessibility, and essential infrastructure development, supporting marginalized communities.
6.7-International Engagement and Support
- ✓International Assistance
Last but not least, seeking international support and cooperation in political conflict can help Pakistan foster an environment conducive to reducing polarization. International organizations like the UN, The World Bank, and IMF, and friendly neighbours such as China, can support Pakistan in ensuring free and fair elections and strengthening democratic institutions, reducing polarization arising from the ideological differences between two major parties led by Imran Khan and the Sharif brothers.
7-Conclusion
To cut it short, Pakistan, at its current time, has been facing a severe setback in socio-economic stability because of the politically polarized environment. Also, mitigating political polarization in Pakistan is an arduous task that requires a sustained, comprehensive, and severe approach involving all stakeholders, including political leaders, civil society, media, and citizens, creating an environment that values inclusivity, tolerance, and democratic principles. However, by addressing the root causes and embracing a culture of dialogue and cooperation, Pakistan can pave the way for a more harmonious political landscape conducive to progress, stability, and national unity. As Bertolt Brecht, a German poet, once said:
“In the contradiction lies the hope.”
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
CSS Solved General Science & Ability Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Miss Iqra Ali & Dr Nishat Baloch, Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students. General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers
