CSS Current Affairs | Impacts of the Balochistan Conflict on Pakistan
The following question about CSS Current Affairs was solved by Hinas Khan Yusofzai under the supervision of Howfiv’s Pakistan Affairs and Current Affairs Coaches. She learnt how to attempt 20 marks question and essay writing from Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Pakistan’s best CSS and PMS English essay and precis teacher with the highest success rate of his students. This solved past paper question is attempted on the pattern taught by Sir to his students, scoring the highest marks in compulsory and optional subjects for years, and uploaded to help aspirants understand how to crack a topic or question, how to write relevantly, what coherence is, and how to include and connect ideas, opinions, and suggestions to score the maximum.
Outline
1-Introduction
2-An overview of the Balochistan conflict
3-Impacts of Balochistan conflict on the state of Pakistan
3.1 Internal impacts
- ✓ Grappling with political instability
- ✓ Experiencing economic contraction
- ✓ Displacing and migration issues
- ✓ Fragmenting into social groups
3.2 External impacts
- ✓ Straining relations with neighbours
- ✓ Hampering the ways for CPEC
- ✓ Dealing with regional security concerns
- ✓ Facing international criticism
3.3 Administrative impacts
- ✓ Damaging infrastructure
- ✓ Exploiting natural resources
- ✓ Grounding region for radicalization
- ✓ Rising of the secessionist movements
4– Suggestion to bring peace in the region by resolving the Balochistan conflict
- ✓ To distribute resources equally
- ✓ To conduct a free and fair election
5-Critical Analysis
6-Conclusion
Answer to the Question
Introduction
The Balochistan conflict, rooted in political marginalization, economic deprivation, and ethnic nationalism, has significantly impacted the state of Pakistan. Since its inception, the province has faced insurgencies primarily driven by demands for greater autonomy, control over resources, and political representation. As the conflict continues, its repercussions on Pakistan’s political, economic, and social landscape have been profound. However, all these challenges and the Balochistan conflict have had profoundly severe internal, external and administrative impacts on the country, which are further weakening and destabilizing the nation’s growth. Hence, this answer discusses the impacts of the Balochistan conflict on the State of Pakistan.
An overview of the Balochistan conflict
The Balochistan conflict is a decades-long insurgency in Pakistan’s largest province, driven by a complex interplay of historical, political, economic, and ethnic factors. In fact, the conflict revolves around Balch nationalists’ demands for greater autonomy, control over natural resources, and addressing human rights abuses. Historical grievances, including the 1948 annexation and subsequent marginalization, have fostered a sense of Baloch identity and resistance; Militant groups, such as the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) and Baloch Republican Army (BRA), have employed guerrilla warfare and terror tactics, while the Pakistani military has responded with force, leading to allegations of human rights abuses and enforced disappearances; Thus, this conflict has resulted in thousands of deaths, displacements, and economic devastation, underscoring the need for meaningful dialogue, reconciliation, and addressing the province’s socio-economic disparities.
Impacts of Balochistan’s Conflict in the State of Pakistan
Hitting the topic requires identifying the impacts of Balochistan’s conflict in the state of Pakistan; these impacts are split into three categories: Internal, external, and administrative.
A-Internal Impacts
The Balochistan conflict has had profoundly severe internal impacts on the country, which are creating hindrances to its stability. Some major internal impacts are mentioned below:
- Grappling with political instability
To begin with, the internal impact of the Balochistan conflict on the state of Pakistan is political instability. The central government’s impotence to address the atrocity of the Baloch people has resulted in multiple revolts and insurgencies. For instance, political alienation, stroked up by the lack of meaningful representation for Baloch leaders in federal structures, has wrecked trust between the region and the central government. This shows that instability in the country gives rise to a threat to the overall federal structure, which risks a breakdown in national cohesion. Therefore, the Balochistan conflict resulted in the worst political upheaval in the country.
- Experiencing economic contraction
Second, the internal impact of the Balochistan conflict on Pakistan is economic contraction. It has strung out the hammering economic growth, which increased regional disparities and undermined national development. Also, the insurgency has disrupted critical infrastructure, deterred investment, and hindered natural resource exploitation, which indicates significant economic losses. According to the World Bank, Baluchistan’s GDP growth rate declined from 3.8% in 2015 to 1.3% in 2020, significantly lower than the national average. Also, the Pakistan Economic Survey, 2022 has reported that the conflict led to a staggering 50% decline in foreign direct investment (FDI) in Balochistan since 2018. This decline is attributed to security concerns, infrastructure damage, and regulatory uncertainties. As a result, the conflict has perpetuated poverty, unemployment, and inequality in the region, further destabilizing the province and sabotaging the country’s economic progress. Therefore, the economic impacts of the Balochistan conflict are far-reaching, increasing the urgent need for a peaceful resolution.
- Displacing and migration issues
Third, the internal impacts of Balochistan conflicts on the state of Pakistan are the displacement and migration of Balochistan locals. In fact, the unbroken violence and insecurity have pulled many families to flee from their ancestral lands, leading to refuge in other provinces or neighbouring countries. According to the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC), over 200,000 people have been displaced in Balochistan since 2015, with many settling in makeshift camps or urban slums, and 45% of these displaced individuals are women and children. This shows that large-scale migration has constrained host communities’ resources, services, and infrastructure, which fuels agitation and social unrest. Thus, the conflict-induced displacement and migration have become critical internal challenges for Pakistan, resulting in crippling social cohesion and compelling comprehensive policy responses.
- Fragmenting into social groups
Fourth, the internal impact of the Balochistan Conflict has shattered the social group fragmentation in Pakistan; these groups foster ethnic and sectarian divisions that undermine national unity and social cohesion. These insurgencies have created a deep-rooted unfairness among the Baloch population, firing sentiments of alienation and marginalization. For instance, the polarization is evident in the increasing sectarian violence between Sunni and Shia populations in Balochistan, with militant groups like the Lashkar-e-Jhangvi exploiting these divisions. This conflict has also jeopardised relations between Balochistan and other provinces, particularly with Punjab, due to perceived differences in the allocation of resources and political representation. Therefore, the conflict has gnawed social capital, shattered national identity, and imperilled the country’s social fabric.
B-External Impacts
The Balochistan conflict has some major external impacts on the state, which are further weakening and smashing the nation. Some are mentioned below:
- Straining relations with neighbours
Starting with first external impact of the Balochistan conflict is straining Pakistan’s relations with its neighbours, worsening tensions in the regional; In fact, these insurgencies has been fueled by cross-border support from neighbouring countries, particularly India, Afghanistan, and Iran, which has led to reciprocal accusations and mistrust, such as Pakistan’s allegations of Indian support to Baloch separatist groups, such as the Baloch Liberation Army, have been met with denials from India, further complicating bilateral relations; Similarly, Afghanistan has accused Pakistan of providing safe havens to Taliban militants operating in Balochistan, straining relations between the two countries; Also, Iran’s concerns over Sunni-Shia sectarian violence in Balochistan have led to raised border tensions and skirmishes; These regional dynamics have hindered cooperation on key issues like counter-terrorism, trade, and energy, undermining regional stability and Pakistan’s diplomatic influence.
- Hampering the ways for CPEC
Second, the Balochistan conflict put forward some crucial challenges to the successful implementation of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), threatening economic growth. As an illustration, attacks on Chinese engineers and workers in Balochistan in 2017 have increased suicide bombings in Gwadar and heightened concerns over safety and risk. Separatist groups like the Baloch Liberation Army have explicitly targeted CPEC projects, such as the Gwadar port and Quetta-Karachi highway. These security risks have led to raised costs, delays, and uncertainty, impeding the corridor’s potential benefits. Thus, the conflict has also fuelled the people of Balochistan’s resentment against CPEC, with many Baloch people perceiving the project as a tool for exploitation rather than progress.
- Dealing with regional security concerns
Third, the Balochistan conflict has far-reaching regional security impacts, threatening stability and putting oil to the fire, leading to extremism across South Asia and the Middle East. The insurgency’s links with transnational terrorist networks, such as Al-Qaeda and the Islamic State, have created concerns about the spread of militancy. For example, the Baloch Liberation Army’s (BLA) ties with the Taliban in Afghanistan have enabled cross-border terrorist movements, inflaming insecurity in both countries. The conflict also lays out a fertile ground for foreign powers to exploit regional rivalries, particularly between India, China, and Pakistan. Therefore, the Balochistan conflict has become a regional security flashpoint, requiring synchronized efforts to address the root factors of instability and extremism.
- Facing international criticism
Furthermore, administrative impacts on Pakistan’s intense international criticism and scrutiny over its handling of the Balochistan conflict damaged its global reputation and isolated it diplomatically. The country’s human rights record, particularly enforced disappearances and extrajudicial killings, has been repeatedly condemned by international organizations and governments. For instance, the United Nations Human Rights Council’s Report in 2022 has expressed concern over Pakistan’s failure to investigate and prosecute security forces responsible for human rights abuses in Balochistan. The US State Department’s annual human rights reports have frequently called attention to Pakistan’s poor human rights record in Balochistan. Thus, these criticisms have not only oxidised Pakistan’s international image but also led to increased diplomatic coercion, aid conditioning, and potential sanctions.
C-Administrative Impacts
The Balochistan conflict has some major administrative impacts on the state, which weakens the nation’s prosperity, such as
- Damaging infrastructure
The first administrative impact is the Balochistan conflict, which has resulted in important harm to the province’s infrastructure, hampering economic development and increasing the region’s under-development. The insurgency has targeted critical infrastructure: roads, bridges, schools, and healthcare facilities. For instance, the 2020 attack on the Quetta-Karachi highway, a vital trade route, disrupted commercial activity and caused millions of dollars in losses. Similarly, the bombing of the Sui gas field in 2012 has led to a 40% reduction in natural gas production, severely impacting Pakistan’s energy sector. Therefore, the destruction of schools and healthcare facilities has repulsed access to education and healthcare services for many Balochis, increasing poverty and inequality in the region.
- Exploiting natural resources
Next, the administrative impacts of the Balochistan conflict on Pakistan are facilitated by the exploitation of the province’s natural resources, sustaining inequality and raising separatist sentiments. This insurgency has created an environment convenient for illegal mining, smuggling, and natural resource extraction, including copper, gold, and natural gas. To illustrate, the Sendak Copper-Gold Project, operated by Chinese companies, has been accused of exploiting Balochistan’s mineral resources without assuming adequate compensation or local community benefits. The illegal exaction of chromite, coal, and other minerals in Balochistan’s tribal areas has improved militant groups and corrupt officials, further unsettling the region. Therefore, Pakistan’s security forces have been bashed for prioritizing extraction of resources over local welfare, increasing atrocity and reinforcing perceptions of colonial-style exploitation.
- Grounding region for radicalization
Furthermore, the Balochistan conflict has created a ground for radicalization, which pulls extremism and militancy among disillusioned youngsters. For instance, the rise of groups like the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) and the Lashkar-e-Balochistan (LeB) has been linked to the marginalization and persecution of Baloch youth, who see violence as a means to achieve self-determination. The enforced disappearances, extrajudicial killings, and human rights abuses by security forces have further radicalized the Baloch population, creating a sense of shared cruelty and collective victimhood. Also, the spread of extremist ideologies through social media and madrassas has increased the radicalization process. Therefore, the Balochistan Conflict impacted on drawing in vulnerable individuals, leading to radicalization and perpetuating a cycle of violence.
- Rising of the secessionist movements
Last but not least, the rising Secessionist movements have spawned due to the Balochistan conflict, which demanded independence from Pakistan and led to further regional instability. The long-lasting outrage of the Baloch people created economic marginalization, political exclusion, and cultural suppression, which have generated separatist sentiments. According to the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA), led by Hyrbyair Marri, has been waging an armed struggle for Balochistan’s independence since 2000, targeting Pakistani security forces and infrastructure. Accordingly, the Baloch Republican Party (BRP), founded by Brahamdagh Bugti, demands a separate Baloch homeland, free from Pakistani control. Therefore, these secessionist movements have gained grip among Baloch youth, who see independence as the only solution to address historical injustices.
Suggestion to Bring Peace in the Region by Resolving Balochistan Conflict
However, the government should take practical measures to develop an environment that would assist the Baloch people in getting their constitutional rights. To begin with, the conduct of free and fair elections would increase local people’s representation and help address the problems of the Balochi people. Furthermore, the government should focus on equal distribution of resources to bring peace to the region and for the development of Balochistan province. Socio-economic development can help Balochi get economic opportunities and allow them to live with freedom; therefore, free and fair elections and equal distribution of resources among the provinces would help decrease the problems women and children face in conflict areas.
Critical Analysis
Under the critical lens, the Balochistan conflict remains a multifarious challenge that strikes the political, economic, and social stability of the country. The state’s over-reliance on military solutions and its failure to address the root causes, such as political representation, resource distribution, and human rights, have provoked the situation. Although efforts have been made, all have fallen short due to the lack of consistency, transparency, and engagement with all stakeholders. Nevertheless, a holistic approach is required to resolve the conflict of Balochistan: The combination of effective political dialogue, comprehensive economic development, human rights respect, and addressing issues of governance; simply put, regional and international diplomacy should be a part of the solution, securing that foreign actors are discouraged from exploiting the situation.
Conclusion
Summing up the above debate, the Balochistan conflict continues to present a significant challenge to Pakistan’s stability and development. Its impacts, ranging from political instability to economic underdevelopment and security risks, highlight the need for a comprehensive, multi-dimensional approach. However, to resolve the conflict, Pakistan Should address the grievances of the Baloch people while ensuring fair governance, equitable resource distribution, and the promotion of human rights, ultimately leading to peace and stability in the region.
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
CSS Solved Islamiyat Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ Islamiyat Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS Islamiyat coach having the highest score of their students.
CSS Solved Islamiyat
CSS Solved General Science & Ability Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students.
CSS Solved General Science & Ability
