CSS & PMS Solved Essay | The Success and Failures of the United Nations
Samra Rafique, a Sir Syed Kazim Ali student, has attempted the CSS & PMS Solved Essay “The Success and Failures of the United Nations” on the given pattern, which Sir Syed Kazim Ali teaches his students. Sir Syed Kazim Ali has been Pakistan’s top English writing and CSS, PMS essay and precis coach with the highest success rate of his students. The essay is uploaded to help other competitive aspirants learn and practice essay writing techniques and patterns to qualify for the essay paper.
Outline
1-Introduction
2-Understanding the United Nations
3-Objectives behind the formation of the United Nations
4-What are the obligations of the United Nations
- Maintaining international peace and security
- Fostering social and economic development
- Protecting human rights globally
5-Failures of the United Nations to fulfil its obligations
- ✓Failure to prevent genocide
- Evidence: The UN’s failing to act decisively during the Rwandan genocide, resulting in the deaths of around 800,000 people
- ✓Inability to halt ethnic cleansing
- Evidence: The UN’s peacekeeping forces being unable to prevent the Srebrenica massacre, resulting in the killing of over 8,000 Bosniak men and boys by Bosnian Serb forces
- ✓Failure to enforce human rights consistently
- Evidence: The UN Human Rights Council being criticized for its perceived bias and ineffectiveness, often failing to address severe human rights abuses in member states like North Korea and Myanmar
- ✓Slow response to the Darfur crisis
- Evidence: The UN’s slow response in deploying peacekeeping forces to the crisis in Darfur Sudan, where widespread atrocities were employed against civilians by militias and the government forces
6- Successes of the United Nations to fulfil its obligations
- ✓Peacekeeping operations
- Evidence: The UN’s peacekeeping mission in Namibia (UNTAG) successfully overseeing the transition to independence in 1990, establishing a stable government
- ✓Conflict mediation
- Evidence: The UN’s mediating the end of the Iran-Iraq War in 1988 through Resolution 598, leading to the ceasefire and subsequent negotiations for a lasting peace
- ✓Promotion of Education
- Evidence: Kenya’s implementing UNESCO’s Education for All (EFA) initiatives, significantly improving access to primary education
- ✓Eradication of diseases
- Evidence: The WHO’s leading an extensive global campaign to eradicate smallpox- a landmark achievement in public health
7-Recommendations for enhancing the effectiveness of the UN
- ✓To strengthen preventive diplomacy and early intervention
- ✓To enhance accountability and transparency
8-Critical analysis
9-Conclusion
The United Nations (UN) is a vital international organization that profoundly influences global peace, security, and development. It has been established with the ambitious goal of fostering international harmony, stability, and cooperation. In this regard, the organization has some obligations, which include maintaining global peace, safeguarding human rights, promoting sustainable development, and upholding international law. With respect to carrying out its responsibilities, the UN navigates a delicate balance between recognition for its successes and criticism for its shortcomings. However, its record is marred by significant failures, including its inability to prevent genocide, halt ethnic cleansing, and respond swiftly to crises such as in Darfur. Additionally, the UN’s persistent struggle to effectively enforce human rights underscores a notable gap between its ideals and practical outcomes. On the positive side, the UN excels in peacekeeping, mediating international conflicts, advancing education, and combating diseases. Therefore, while acknowledging the UN’s accomplishments, it is crucial to identify areas for improvement. In this respect, institutional reforms are vital to strengthen the organization’s impact and credibility. Furthermore, preventive diplomacy and early interventions are necessary to enhance accountability and transparency. This essay comprehensively illustrates the successes and failures of the organization by discussing its obligations.
Understanding the United Nations (UN), it is an international non-profit organization established in 1945 following the Second World War by 51 countries to promote political and economic cooperation among its member states. The UN functions through six primary organs: the General Assembly, the Security Council, the International Court of Justice, the Secretariat, the Economic and Social Council, and the Trusteeship Council. Additionally, it encompasses various specialized agencies and programs dedicated to addressing specific concerns, such as health, education, science, culture, food and agriculture, and more. While these agencies operate independently, they also collaborate within the broader UN framework. Furthermore, the UN Charter, the organization’s foundational treaty, delineates its purposes and principles, underscoring concepts of sovereignty, equality, and non-interference. With over 190 member states participating in the UN’s General Assembly, the organization is comprised of a complex and multifaceted entity within the broader United Nations system.
Coming towards the objectives of the formation of the United Nations, the organization was established in the aftermath of the Second World War with the primary objective of promoting global peace, reducing international tensions, preventing large-scale conflicts, and safeguarding human rights. It replaced the League of Nations, which was formed in 1920 after the First World War, but ultimately failed in its mission to prevent another major war. Following the devastation of the Second World War, the United Nations was created in 1945 with a renewed commitment and an enhanced framework to prevent future global conflicts. According to Article 1 of the UN Charter, the organization has four main objectives: first, maintaining international peace and security; second, fostering friendly relations among nations based on equal rights and self-determination; third, promoting international cooperation to address economic, social, cultural, and humanitarian issues; and fourth, upholding and encouraging respect for human rights. Additionally, the UN is a central coordinating body for member states’ efforts to achieve these goals.
Following its stated objectives, the United Nations (UN) is entrusted with various mandates to accomplish its fundamental objectives, encompassing vital obligations crucial to its mission. Foremost among these is the maintenance of international peace and security. The UN addresses this by engaging in conflict prevention and peacekeeping operations and, when necessary, by imposing sanctions or military interventions authorized by the Security Council. Additionally, the UN is vital in promoting social and economic development, addressing issues such as poverty, education, healthcare, and sustainable development through its specialized agencies. Safeguarding human rights is another critical responsibility, with the UN overseeing global conditions, reporting violations, and taking action against abuses through the Human Rights Council. Moreover, the UN encourages international cooperation by providing a platform for dialogue, coordinating global efforts on climate change and pandemics, and advocating for economic and social progress. By fulfilling these duties, the UN strives to establish a peaceful, fair, and prosperous world, adhering to the principles of its Charter and effectively responding to global challenges.
Delving into the notable failures, the United Nations (UN) has faced significant criticisms for its shortcomings in certain areas. One of the most glaring failures is its inability to prevent genocide. For instance, the UN failed to act decisively during the Rwandan genocide in 1994, resulting in the deaths of around 800,000 people. This failure was due to a lack of political will and inadequate resources. When the genocide began, the UN peacekeepers were present but were not given the mandate or reinforcements needed to stop the mass killings. The devastating impact of this inaction led to widespread trauma, displacement, and a prolonged period of instability in the region. Thus, this tragic event underscores the UN’s inability to respond effectively to urgent humanitarian crises and protect vulnerable populations from mass atrocities.
In a similar vein, another notable failure is the UN’s inability to halt ethnic cleansing. For example, the UN peacekeeping forces were unable to prevent the Srebrenica massacre between 1992 and 1995, where over 8,000 Bosniak men and boys were killed by Bosnian Serb forces. Despite the presence of UN troops, they were not authorized to use force to protect civilians effectively. This massacre had severe repercussions, causing a deep rift between ethnic groups and leaving a legacy of grief and injustice that still impacts the region today. Moreover, the inability to prevent such atrocities has had long-lasting effects on regional stability and ethnic relations, perpetuating a cycle of distrust and violence. Indeed, the massacre of Srebrenica is a stain on the history of the United Nations. Thus, this incident highlights the limitations of UN peacekeeping missions, particularly in scenarios where robust military intervention is required to protect civilians.
Moreover, the UN has been criticized for its failure to enforce human rights consistently. For example, the UN Human Rights Council has often been perceived as biased and ineffective, frequently failing to address severe human rights abuses in member states such as North Korea and Myanmar. According to a report by the Guardian, the council has been accused of turning a blind eye to gross violations due to political considerations and the influence of member states with poor human rights records. The report highlights that political alliances and the rotating membership of the council often result in selective enforcement of human rights, where some violations are ignored while others are condemned. This inconsistency allows oppressive regimes to continue their abuses with impunity, undermining global human rights standards and diminishing the credibility of international advocacy. Consequently, this selective enforcement undermines the UN’s authority and effectiveness in upholding human rights globally.
Additionally, the UN’s response to the crisis in Darfur, Sudan, from 2003 to the present, represents a significant failure. The organization faced criticism for its delayed deployment of peacekeeping forces, which allowed militias and government forces to commit widespread atrocities against civilians unabated. According to an Al Jazeera report, despite early warnings of impending violence, the UN Security Council failed to authorize adequate intervention measures promptly, leading to the mass killing of over 300,000 people and the displacement of 2.7 million people. This report clearly indicates that the delay contributed to a prolonged period of violence and suffering in Darfur. Bureaucratic inefficiencies and a lack of timely international support compounded this slow response, resulting in lasting social and economic impacts and exacerbating poverty and regional instability. This failure underscores the UN’s challenges in mobilizing timely and effective responses to emerging humanitarian disasters. Hence, the Darfur crisis is a stark example of the UN’s difficulties in effectively intervening to protect vulnerable populations in conflict zones.
Despite its numerous challenges, the United Nations (UN) has made significant strides in various areas, demonstrating its capacity to promote global peace. One of the most notable successes of the UN is its peacekeeping operations, which have played a crucial role in stabilizing post-conflict regions and facilitating transitions to peace. For instance, the UN’s peacekeeping mission in Namibia (UNTAG) is a prime example of its effectiveness. This mission successfully oversaw Namibia’s transition to independence in 1990, establishing a stable government and setting a precedent for future peacekeeping efforts. The success of UNTAG illustrates the UN’s ability to manage complex political transitions and contribute to long-term stability in conflict-affected areas. Thus, these achievements underscore the essential role of the UN in fostering global peace and security.
Another significant achievement of the UN is its role in conflict mediation. The UN has been instrumental in bringing warring parties to the negotiating table and securing lasting peace agreements. A notable case is the UN’s mediation of the Iran-Iraq War. Through Resolution 598, the UN facilitated the end of this devastating conflict in 1988, leading to a ceasefire and subsequent negotiations for a lasting peace. This successful mediation effort underscores the UN’s critical role in resolving international disputes and fostering diplomatic solutions over prolonged military engagements. Thus, the UN’s ability to mediate such high-stakes conflicts and secure peace agreements showcases its essential function in maintaining global stability and security.
In addition to its peacekeeping and mediation efforts, the UN has made remarkable progress in promoting education worldwide. UNESCO, a specialized agency of the UN, has implemented various initiatives to enhance educational access and quality. One striking example is Kenya’s implementation of UNESCO’s Education for All (EFA) initiatives. These efforts significantly improved access to primary education in Kenya. Kenya’s Minister of Education, George Saitoti, highlighted the impact, says, “UNESCO’s Education for All initiative has transformed our education system, ensuring that every child has the opportunity to learn and thrive.” This demonstrates the UN’s impact on educational development by supporting countries’ educational reforms. The UN helps ensure that more children receive the basic education necessary for personal and national development. Consequently, the UN’s commitment to education underscores its broader mission of fostering global development and empowerment through learning.
Moreover, the UN has successfully eradicated diseases, improving global public health. The World Health Organization (WHO), a specialized agency of the UN, led a global campaign to wipe out smallpox. According to a report by Al Jazeera, the WHO’s campaign against smallpox involved extensive vaccination programs and surveillance efforts, resulting in the last natural case of smallpox being recorded in Somalia in 1977. This pivotal moment led to the official declaration of smallpox eradication by the World Health Assembly in 1980. The successful eradication of smallpox illustrates the UN’s capacity to mobilize international resources and coordinate effective global health initiatives, thereby saving millions of lives. Thus, this accomplishment not only underscores the UN’s effectiveness in addressing global health challenges but also establishes a benchmark for future international health efforts.
Looking ahead, to avoid repeating past mistakes, the United Nations needs to adopt practical solutions. To start with, the organization should enhance its ability to respond quickly to new crises by making peacekeeping operations more efficient and flexible. By creating a better-equipped and more agile rapid response force, the UN can intervene promptly in cases of genocide, ethnic cleansing, and other humanitarian emergencies. Additionally, making the Council’s operations and decision-making processes more transparent will improve its credibility. This increased transparency would help prevent tragedies like those in Rwanda and Srebrenica, where delays and indecision led to severe loss of life and suffering.
Furthermore, the UN should focus on preventing conflicts before they escalate. This means taking a proactive approach to spot and address potential problems early. Strengthening early warning systems and investing in mediation and dialogue initiatives can help stop conflicts from getting out of control. For instance, prioritizing preventive diplomacy in unstable regions could lower the risk of ethnic cleansing and genocide. By emphasizing prevention, the UN can save lives and reduce the need for expensive, complicated peacekeeping missions.
Presenting the final analysis of the whole debate, the United Nations is undeniably a cornerstone of international diplomacy and humanitarian efforts. In conflict and humanitarian crises, many nations turn to the UN to foster global cooperation. Undoubtedly, the UN provides hope and a platform for dialogue, peacekeeping, and development initiatives, striving to promote international stability and security. Nevertheless, among various other shortcomings, the UN’s inefficiencies and the political gridlock within its structure often undermine its integrity and effectiveness. This not only affects the organization’s credibility but also hampers the timely and effective resolution of critical global issues. The simple truth is that while the UN has the noble mandate to promote peace and development, its structural and operational limitations sometimes prevent it from fully realizing this mission. To summarize, despite its major flaws, the United Nations (UN) remains an important institution in promoting global peace, security, and development. Established in the aftermath of World War II, the UN has made considerable achievements in areas such as peacekeeping, conflict resolution, education, and public health, as seen by triumphs, such as Namibia’s independence transition, mediation in the Iran-Iraq war, and smallpox eradication. However, its failings, particularly in averting genocides, halting ethnic cleansing, and consistently upholding human rights, expose fundamental gaps between its principles and its results. To improve its effectiveness, the UN must implement necessary reforms, including strengthening the responsiveness and flexibility of peacekeeping operations, increasing the Security Council’s transparency and accountability, and investing in preventative diplomacy and early intervention tactics. By addressing these structural and operational limitations, the UN would be able to better fulfil its mandate and adapt to the changing global landscape, ultimately reinforcing its role to achieve long-term peace and sustainable development in a world fraught with challenges.
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
CSS Solved General Science & Ability Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Miss Iqra Ali & Dr Nishat Baloch, Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students. General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers
