CSS Current Affairs | Scenarios for the Future of the Palestine Conflict
The following question about CSS Current Affairs was solved by Hinas Khan Yusofzai under the supervision of Howfiv’s Pakistan Affairs and Current Affairs Coaches. She learnt how to attempt 20 marks question and essay writing from Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Pakistan’s best CSS and PMS English essay and precis teacher with the highest success rate of his students. This solved past paper question is attempted on the pattern taught by Sir to his students, scoring the highest marks in compulsory and optional subjects for years, and uploaded to help aspirants understand how to crack a topic or question, how to write relevantly, what coherence is, and how to include and connect ideas, opinions, and suggestions to score the maximum.
Outline
The examiner asked two things about this specific question: First, the potential scenarios for the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict. Second, the factors that are likely to shape the outcomes of the future of Israel Palestine conflict. So, to achieve a higher score, you have to make sure that you are giving solid arguments related to both parts. Also, keep the exam timing in mind and attempt according to the 20 marks. here an outline is given, followed by an introduction, critical analysis and conclusion.
Outline
1-Introduction
2- An overview of the conflict history
3- Throwing light on the potential scenarios for the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict
- ✓ Envisioningtwo nation-states with two governments
- ✓ Establishing one nation of Israel-Palestine state with shared governance
- ✓ Ongoing state of conflict unresolved
- ✓ Involving regional and international states in coalition to create peace
- ✓ Escalating leading to border regional wars
4- Spotlighting the factors that are likely to shape the outcomes of the future of the Palestine conflict
- ✓ Evolving Israel and Palestinians’ dynamics
- ✓ Increasing international Community involvement and intervention
- ✓ Intensifying public opinion and civil society activism both locally and globally
- ✓ Shifting regional dynamics amidst Iranian, turkey, and Arab states influences
- ✓ Mediating role of the US in peace efforts
5- Critical Analysis
6- Conclusion
Answer to the Question
Introduction
The Israel-Palestine conflict is a longstanding dispute over land, religious identity, and political control between Jewish Israelites and Arab Muslims. Indeed, Palestine is the most well-documented genocide in history, yet the most denied; this conflict is a deep-rooted struggle, primarily over land and national identity. It started in the early 20th century between Jews and Arab populations in British-controlled Palestine; The conflict intensified after the creation of the Jewish state in 1948, which led to the displacement of millions of Palestinians; Subsequent wars, in 1967 and 1973, has led to the Israeli settlements, territorial disputes, and security concerns with stalled peace efforts have led the cycle of violence and deepened the behaviors of mistrust on both sides; However, the future of the Israel-Palestine conflicts has the multiple potential scenarios, which will probably change the future of the both Israel and Palestine in future; For instance, these scenarios includes: the two nation state solution, Bi-national state, which would lead toward evolving Israel and Palestinians dynamics, increasing international communities involvement and intervention; Thus, this answer discusses the future possible scenarios of Israel and Palestine conflict and factors that are likely to shape due to these scenarios.
An overview timeline of the Israel-Palestine conflict
| 1800-1900 | Foundation of Modern Tension | Zionists Movement Started by Theodore Herzl |
| 1917 | Balfour Declaration | Britishers supported the “national home for the Jewish people” in Palestine, then part of the Ottoman Empire. |
| 1920-1948 | British Mandate and Increased Tensions | 1920 The League of Nations grants Britain Control over Palestine After World War I. 1936-1939 Arab Palestinians Revolt against British Colonial Rule and Jewish Immigration. 1947 The United Nations Proposes a Partition of Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab States, With Jerusalem Under International Administration. Jewish Leaders accept the plan, While Arab Leaders reject It. |
| 1948-19967 | Creation of Israel and the First Major Wars | 1948 The independence of Israel & First Arab-Israeli War happened. The War Ends In 1949, while Israel expanded Its Territory. Hundreds Of thousands of Palestinians were displaced. 1957 Suez Crisis: Egypt Nationalizes the Suez Canal, Prompting an Invasion by Israel, the UK, and France. 1964 PLO founded: the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) was built with the aim of establishing an Arab State in Palestine. |
| 1967-1980 | Occupation and Peace Attempts | 1967 Six-Day War: Israel launched a Pre-emptive Strike against Egypt, Jordan, and Syria, Capturing the West Bank, Gaza Strip, East Jerusalem, Sinai Peninsula, and Golan Heights. 1973 Yom Kippur War: Egypt and Syria launched a surprise attack on Israeli-held territories. After Initial Setbacks, Israel Regains Control with the U.S. Ceasefire. 1978 Camp David Accords: Egypt’s President Anwar Sadat and Israel’s Prime Minister Menachem Begin signed a peace treaty in which Egypt recognized Israel, and Israel returned to the Sinai Peninsula. |
| 1987-2000 | Intifadas and the Oslo Accords | 1987 First Intifada: The Palestinian Uprising against Israeli Occupation began in the West Bank and Gaza, which led to unrest & a heavy Israeli Military response. 1993-1995 Oslo Accords: The PLO, led by Yasser Arafat, and Israel signed the Oslo Accords, which established a framework for a Two-State Solution and Palestinian self-governance in parts of the West Bank and Gaza. 2000 Second Intifada: After Failed Peace Talks, a Second Palestinian Uprising erupted, marked by Suicide bombings and Military responses. |
| 2005-2020 | Ongoing Conflict, Blockades, and Escalations | Aerial Bombardment The Israeli military’s Aerial bombardment of Gaza was unprecedented; entire neighbourhoods were destroyed. Casualties Over 22,000 Palestinians in Gaza Were Killed, and more than 58,000 others were injured, According to the reports of the Gaza Ministry of Health. Humanitarian Crisis The Humanitarian Situation in Gaza was Catastrophic, with 1.9 million Palestinians displaced and 85% of the Population in need of Humanitarian assistance. |
| 17th Oct 2023- Present | Israel Massacre and Genocide Of Palestine | Aerial Bombardment The Israeli military’s Aerial bombardment of Gaza was unprecedented; entire neighborhoods were destroyed. Casualties Over 22,000 Palestinians in Gaza Were Killed, and more than 58,000 others were injured, According to the reports of the Gaza Ministry of Health. Humanitarian Crisis The Humanitarian Situation in Gaza was Catastrophic, with 1.9 million Palestinians displaced and 85% of the Population in need of Humanitarian assistance. |
Throwing light on the potential scenarios for the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict
- Envisioning two nation-states with two governments
The First and foremost potential scenario for the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict is a nation-state with two different governments. When Israel and Palestinians operate as distinct nations, it can lead toward a clear establishment of borders, recognizing each state’s sovereignty. Also, Jerusalem would be serving as a shared capital under international oversight to honour its significance to both groups. For that reason, both governments can build cooperation on issues such as security, resource management, economic growth, and mutual dependence. Illustratively, Belgium’s federalism: Power-sharing between Flemish and Walloon communities. This shows that with mutual respect and an unwavering commitment to peaceful coexistence, a two-state solution would transform the region, creating an environment where both Israelis and Palestinians thrive independently yet in harmony.
- Establishing one nation of Israel-Palestine state with shared governance
Second, a potential scenario for the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict is establishing a single nation or a bi-national state of Israel-Palestine with shared governance, which offers a viable solution to the longstanding conflict. This one nation-state would ensure equal rights, citizenship, and representation for Israelis and Palestinians; therefore, a shared government would address core issues that include borders, security, and Jerusalem’s status, which fosters cooperation and mutual understanding. As a demonstration, South Africa’s post-apartheid Truth and Reconciliation Commission has addressed the historical injustices through dialogue. Thus, through pooling resources and expertise, the nation would leverage its economic strengths to promote regional stability and prosperity.
- Ongoing state of conflict unresolved.
Third, a potential scenario for the future of the Israel-Palestine issue is the ongoing unresolved tensions. In fact, it might lead to prolonged cycles of violence, instability, and humanitarian crises Due to the not signing any peace agreement from 17 October 2023 to the present day, which further fuels more fire between Israeli forces and Palestinian groups, which leads towards more civilian casualties, economic hardship, and displacement; To illustrate, current escalations have shown how Palestinians suffering by losing their loved ones, and destruction of their property; This shows the resentment and fuel extremism on both sides which makes future negotiations even more challenging; Hence, a lack of resolution would deepen divides and prevent the region from achieving peace and prosperity.
- Involving regional and international states coalition to create peace
Fourth, a potential scenario for the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict is a collaborative effort from regional and international states to establish lasting peace in this region. Indeed, genuine assistance and a multilateral coalition of the United States, European Union, United Nations, Arab League, and neighbouring countries would provide the required diplomatic support. Historical examples, like the Quartet on the Middle East and the Arab Peace Initiative, demonstrate the potential for collective action. This shows that with a coalition, these states can facilitate negotiations by pooling expertise and addressing core issues like borders, Jerusalem, and refugees.
- Escalating, leading to border regional wars
Last but not least, a potential scenario for the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict is the ignition of wider regional wars. Various neighbouring countries have aligned themselves with either side. For instance, groups like Hezbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in Gaza have historically supported Palestinian resistance against Israel. This support has included financial aid, arms, and strategic guidance, which has created a web of alliances that can quickly escalate into a larger conflict if these groups or nations intervene directly in the event of a major Israeli-Palestinian confrontation. Additionally, tensions between Israel and nearby Arab nations, including Syria and Lebanon, create a fragile border dynamic that would easily lead to destruction spilling over national boundaries, especially if these countries perceive a threat to their interests. Thus, the conflict risks and increases without significant diplomatic intervention and fuels massive regional wars.
Spotlighting the factors that are likely to shape the outcomes of the future of the Palestine conflict
- Evolving Israel and Palestinians’ dynamics
Moving ahead, factors that are likely to shape the outcomes of the future of Israel-Palestinian are its evolving dynamics. In fact, the Palestinian’s young generation is increasingly vocal about seeking solutions, as they are weary of decades of conflict impacting their daily life. Illustratively, the normalization agreements between Israel, UAE and Bahrain, which have established diplomatic ties with Israel under the Abraham Accords. These accords show a shift among some Arab states to prioritize regional stability and economic cooperation over long-standing political stances; contrarily, the Palestinian leadership often views these agreements as undermining their cause. Therefore, this new reality illustrates that when regional relationships change, the nature of the Israel-Palestine conflict also changes, which leads to a situation that would either open new pathways to peace or further complicate longstanding tension.
- Increasing international Community involvement and intervention
Moreover, increasing international community involvement and intervention is another factor. When global awareness grows because of the humanitarian and political dimensions of the conflict, organizations like the United Nations, the European Union, and influential countries begin to call more urgently for peace negotiations and rights-based solutions. For instance, recent UN resolutions and initiatives by European Union leaders have condemned violent escalations and called for a sustainable two-state solution, which has emphasized human rights protections for Palestinians. This shows a broader shift toward accountability due to international actors recognizing that inaction could perpetuate regional instability and deepen the humanitarian crisis. Since October 7, 2023, Norway, Ireland, and Spain have joined the list of countries formally recognizing Palestine’s statehood, contributing to a growing international trend. This movement may encourage additional nations to follow suit. As of now, 146 out of 193 United Nations member states recognize Palestine as a sovereign nation. Therefore, the increasing role of the international community holds promise for facilitating a resolution which supports a peaceful future for the region.
- Intensifying public opinion and civil society activism both locally and globally
Additionally, local and global pressures of public opinion and civil society activism are other important factors likely to shape the future outcomes of the Israel-Palestine conflict. Taking a recent year example into account, especially among younger generations worldwide, grassroots movements, advocacy groups, and social media campaigns have brought widespread attention to issues of human rights, political autonomy, and the humanitarian impact of the Israel-Palestine conflict. This shift is reflected in the growing number of public demonstrations, petitions, and advocacy events worldwide that demand fairer, rights-based solutions to the Israel-Palestine conflict. All these voices would become louder and will pressure political leaders domestically and internationally to consider policies that reflect these shared concerns. Therefore, the power of public opinion and civil society activism in amplifying awareness is set to be a factor likely to change the path forward in the Israel-Palestine conflict.
- Shifting regional dynamics amidst Iranian, turkey, and Arab states influences
Furthermore, shifting regional dynamics, especially the influences of Turkey, Iran and various Arab states, are significant factors likely to shape the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict. In this conflict, Iran has emerged stronger than Israel, considering the Israeli counterstrike on October 26, 2024, was half-hearted. The response came after Iran’s robust salvo toward Israel, Operation True Promise 1 and 2. Israel’s outdated countermeasure seems to have yielded to international pressure. This strategic shift will benefit Iran and its proxies, marking a significant setback for the US in the region. Indeed, all these nations are playing a unique role in the region, influencing the political and military strategies by aligning themselves with different sides of the Israel-Palestine conflict. As a demonstration, they have long supported the Palestinian fighter group ‘Hamas’ by providing resources and funds to counter Israel’s military and the United States’ influence in the region. On the other side, the Arab states’ stances have evolved. Initially, they were only supporting Palestinians, but since the signing of the Abraham Accords, its relations with Israel have become normalized, which indicates a shift towards prioritizing regionalstability in the region and also countering shared threats such as Iran. Thus, through these shifting alliances and rivalries, either a complex regional landscape will be created, or peaceful negotiations will be ensured.
- Mediating role of the US in peace efforts
Lastly, the factor that is likely to change the outcome of the Israel-Palestine conflict is the US mediating role in peace efforts in the region. The US has always supported Israel and ignored the Palestinians by providing it financially and militarily. For instance, the current approach emphasizes multilateral support rather than unilateral intervention, which tends to seek regional allies to share responsibility. But too much supporting Israel has badly affected America, as its own citizens are moving against the Joe Biden hypocrisy. Israel’s longstanding disregard for international law, in its obstruction of Gaza humanitarian aid and restrictive West Bank policies, has exposed the myth of its democratic status in the region. Currently, humanitarian support to Palestinians by the US is offering the two-state solution as the only way to peace. However, the US has noticed that ignoring Palestinians will cause them to lose their influence in Muslim countries, and hence, it shifted towards its domestic priorities, focusing on strategic concerns in the region, such as Asia-Pacific, potentially reducing its active involvement in Middle Eastern affairs. Additionally, public opinion of American citizens has shown a growing awareness of the humanitarian aspects of the conflict, which influences policymakers to adopt a more balanced stance on human rights issues.
Critical Analysis
Critically,In Israel Palestine conflict, different scenarios can be practiced in future, as the Palestine has gained more momentum, in the 21st century and treated as a last colonial project, with former colonies standing more firmly in solidarity; Contrarily, the Israeli war crimes will haunt the West for years to come, as they blatantly boosted their weapon industries and profited from the 21st century’s genocide, which was documented and witnessed globally; The Western facade of human rights advocacy has been shattered by the genocide, and invites a fierce international criticism and opposition whenever they try to promote human rights; Moreover, the pager attacks in Lebanon have raised concerns about the reliability of distributors handling technology-related goods, potentially destabilizing the global supply chain; Meanwhile, Iran might declare itself a nuclear-armed country, as tensions have accelerated its nuclear program, especially following the alleged killing of Ismail Haniyeh, Hamas’ political leader, on Iranian soil; Therefore, all the possible outcome that are likely to shape the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict are involving the region other’s state, political leadership of those states, international involvement, and public protests will definitely lead to free Palestine state. Palestine is the cement that holds the Arab world together, or it is the explosive that blows it apart.
Conclusion
Wrapping up the whole debate, the future of the Israel-Palestine conflict can be anything depending upon the possible potential scenario and its outcome. Each scenario is shaped by complex factors that include political leadership, involvement of foreign countries and societal attitudes. One possible scenario would be a nations state, where both Palestine and Israel will be sovereign entities with separate borders; Another important scenario would be one binational state, in which both Palestinians and Israelites would have a single government, which would either provide equal rights for all or result in ongoing tensions, as demographic and political challenges may create obstacles to equal representation; Moreover, the third scenario envisions continued status quo, which would be marked by periodic escalations and ceasefires, which has influenced by entrenched positions and internal political pressures that prevent meaningful negotiations; Simply put, these outcome will likely to shape: a blend of diplomatic breakthroughs, shifts in public sentiment, and geopolitical changes, which collectively will determine whether the region sees sustained peace or prolonged strife.
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
CSS Solved Islamiyat Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ Islamiyat Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS Islamiyat coach having the highest score of their students.
CSS Solved Islamiyat
CSS Solved General Science & Ability Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students.
CSS Solved General Science & Ability
