CSS 2010 Solved Current Affairs Past Paper | Aghaz-e-Haqooq Baluchistan Package
The following question of CSS Current Affairs 2010 is solved by Sir Ammar Hashmi, the best Current Affairs Coach, on the guided pattern of Sir Syed Kazim Ali, which he taught to his students, scoring the highest marks in compulsory subjects for years. This solved past paper question is uploaded to help aspirants understand how to crack a topic or question, write relevantly, what coherence is, and how to include and connect ideas, opinions, and suggestions to score the maximum.
Question breakdown
This question requires an analysis of the Aghaz-e-Haqooq Baluchistan Package.
Outline
1-Introduction
2-Background of the Aghaz-e-Haqooq Baluchistan Package
3-Key Features of the Package
- ✓Increased provincial autonomy and control over resources
- ✓Economic and job development initiatives for Baloch youth
- ✓Human rights reforms addressing enforced disappearances
4-Challenges and Criticism
- ✓Slow and inconsistent implementation of reforms
- ✓Baloch scepticism over promises of autonomy
- ✓Perception of short-term political appeasement, not long-term solutions
5-Political and Societal Impacts
- ✓Partially improved federal-provincial relations
- ✓Economic benefits are felt, but limited
6-Critical Analysis
7-Conclusion
Answer to the Question
Introduction
The Aghaz-e-Haqooq Baluchistan Package was ministerially announced by the Government of Pakistan in 2009 because of aggravated Baluchistan issues with bearing on politics, economies and human rights. This package is intended to decentralize provincial authority and overall provincial resource management, provide for economic equality, and address other concerns, such as enforced disappearances. Nevertheless, the authorities encountered difficulties implementing a package on such a large scale, and the Baloch community expressed doubts about the sincerity of the government’s intentions. Finally, the package was a goodwill gesture of returning the irreconcilable foes. However, it exposed the challenges of managing structural regional issues in Pakistan.
Background of the Aghaz-e-Haqooq Baluchistan Package
The Aghaz-e-Haqooq Baluchistan Package was introduced against emerging tensions in Baluchistan based on political marginalization, economic neglect and human rights abuses. Baluchistan had, historically, been rich in natural resources. However, it has enjoyed the benefits of its resources very little, which has made the province’s people very unhappy. The federal government launched this package as a tool to solve these grievances by improving federal-provincial relations and taking cognizance of the problems being faced by the Baloch people. The package was a reconciliation measure between the Baloch community and the federal government to build trust.
Key Features of the Package
- ✓ Increased provincial autonomy and control over resources
One of the critical features was to increase provincial autonomy and control over resources. Therefore, as natural resources had been a long-standing point of contention, the package was supposed to give provinces more control over what to do with them. Resources in Baluchistan were rich but had benefited little from them historically because revenues were centrally controlled. The package included measures to empower the provincial government, such as allowing Baluchistan to retain a more significant share of gas and mineral resources profits, thus paving the way to self-sufficiency. While this reflected broader federal changes seeking to rely on provincial autonomy, it was targeted specifically to Baluchistan’s particular requirements.
- ✓ Economic and job development initiatives for Baloch youth
Another key feature of the package was to offer economic development efforts to cut Baloch unemployment and give Baloch youth job opportunities. In this regard, the package was designated to provide job quotas in federal jobs and infrastructure investment in local projects like Gwadar Port. Moreover, the goal was to help the local people directly, as these efforts would generate sustainable employment and pull the provincial economy out of its unearned lags.
- ✓ Human rights reforms addressing enforced disappearances
The package also attempted to deal with human rights matters with an emphasis on enforced disappearances, which caused distrust. The creation of a commission for probing such cases was one of the prominent steps in rebuilding Baloch’s confidence in the federal government. This could have been intended to show a willingness to be accountable to the people, an aspect the locals called a hindrance to peace. In a nutshell, the Aghaz e Haqooq Baluchistan Package was a combination of multifaceted issues plaguing Baluchistan for decades, including resource control, economic upliftment, and human rights. Nevertheless, implementing such promises depends on their effectiveness and the continuing federal commitment.
Challenges and Criticism
- ✓ Slow and inconsistent implementation of reforms
There were many challenges and criticisms, but the slow and inconsistent implementation of the reforms was one of the main criticisms of the package. The population of Baloch, though promised changes, particularly changes in resource control, job creation, and so forth, needed to materialise faster, which fuelled scepticism. It could have created trust when the government could not fulfil these promises. It only eroded that trust and created suspicion on whether the government would be willing to honour its demands for action and genuine change.
- ✓ Baloch scepticism over promises of autonomy
Moreover, the package promised more autonomy, but many Baloch leaders wondered if the promises would be kept. That scepticism came partly from historical grievances concerning federal control over Baluchistan’s resources and decision-making authority. Some perceived that the package was superficial and did not go deep enough to respond to their demands for authentic self-rule.
- ✓ Perception of short-term political appeasement, not long-term solutions
There was also an impression that the package was the sort of government offer to address political instability instead of remedies that would help solve problems permanently. Opponents claimed that such a package could have been better since more of a symbolic effort was made towards addressing symptoms of discontent in Baluchistan rather than the causes. This was because some people seemed to fear that with no strategic approach to the issue, the promise of holding on to the reforms may not deliver lasting peace in the region, let alone development. These features and criticisms, in general, showed that despite some potential to resolve crucial problems as embodied in the package, the problems portrayed here demonstrate the realities of the obstacles to actualising the intended benefits.
Political and Societal Impacts
- ✓ Partially improved federal-provincial relations
The federal government did the package to give attention to a vendor that Baluchistan has been sidelined for decades. It became a means by which federal-provincial exchanges could become more frequent and direct, in this case, under the veneer of promises for greater decentralization and greater control over resources. To a certain extent, this served the purpose of allaying tension, balancing in favour of the political process, and making the Baloch leaders feel welcomed. However, trust was still lacking because previous wounds had not healed, and many considered the package inadequate due to the problems they were facing in Baluchistan.
- ✓ Economic benefits felt but limited
Even though a portion of the package was directed towards increasing economic development through employment programmes and youth training and development, the ability to deliver on the promise needed to be more lustre and minimal. For example, generations of employees were employed in areas such as public administration and infrastructural development; however, most were confined to cities and towns such as Quetta. On the other hand, rural societies, which comprised significant parts of Baluchistan and experienced severe economic problems, did not have much direct bearing. Further, a few initiatives or activities, like offering internships for young graduates and skill development centres for technical training, were begun but still needed to be implemented throughout the province. This uneven advancement resulted in the notion that the claimed economic initiatives needed to be improved, as only a segment of the target population benefited from change.
Critical Analysis
To critically analyse Balochistan’s Aghaz-e Haqooq Baluchistan Package, it was a significant federal effort to address the deep-rooted Baluchistan grievances. However, implementation suffered setbacks, and there was scepticism about federal intentions. The package contained promises for such essential reforms as greater provincial control over natural resources, but they were suspiciously promised. The federal government had not left a good impression on the people of the Baloch, mainly when it came to committing to things, and both those promises had been left unfulfilled in the past, leaving the people of the Baloch to wonder if these changes would come to pass anxiously. Bureaucratic delays also slowed efforts to stop enforced disappearances. However, economic infrastructure projects, particularly the development of infrastructure, did not reach the remote region of the province, which ultimately fuelled doubts about the sincerity of the federal response at the same time. However, another criticism of the package was the lack of local representation in the planning and execution of the package, which made many adhere to the impression that the package was nothing more than a short-term appeasement to Baluchistan’s problems.
Conclusion
To conclude, though the Aghaz-e-Haqooq Baluchistan Package was an excellent initiative to deal with Balochistan’s long-standing causes, it proved deficient in actualization. Rather than providing economic relief and helping improve federal-provincial relations, the package has been beset with slow execution and a lack of trust with the local population. For Baloch citizens, this initiative was perceived as lacking real federal commitment and a weak local presence, and many needed to be convinced that permanent change would result. Nevertheless, meaningful progress can only be achieved through a more comprehensive approach—based on solid political will, efficient implementation and actual local participation. Any chance the federal government will have at lifting the deep-rooted issues in Baluchistan and creating a more inclusive and equitable future will only be possible through such an expression.
CSS Solved Past Papers’ Essays
Looking for the last ten years of CSS and PMS Solved Essays and want to know how Sir Kazim’s students write and score the highest marks in the essays’ papers? Then, click on the CSS Solved Essays to start reading them.
CSS Solved Essays
CSS Solved Current Affairs Past Papers
Looking for the last fifteen years of CSS Solved Current Affairs to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS Current Affairs coach having the highest score of their students.
CSS Solved Current Affairs
CSS Solved General Science & Ability Past Papers
Want to read the last ten years’ General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers to learn how to attempt them and to score high? Let’s click on the link below to read them all freely. All past papers have been solved by Pakistan’s top CSS GSA coach having the highest score of their students.
General Science & Ability Solved Past Papers
